9 Presidents Who Were Not Pet Lovers

History Shows Nine U.S. Presidents Who Were Not Pet Lovers

By S. R. Morris

There are several lists of presidential pets. The lists include the most exotic pets, the most unusual or dangerous pets, and there are even lists of the most dogs, cats, or birds owned by a president. But this is a list you may have never seen before.

This was compiled from a variety of books and sources. Since much time has elapsed and, no living witnesses can attest whether they were pet lovers or not, an amount of common sense had to be applied to compile this list.

The first three on the list are agreed by most historians. While some may argue about what degree of love or apathy these presidents had toward animals, the following list portrays the presidents who “probably” did not love pets.

#1: Chester Alan Arthur (1881-1885) There is no trace of any pets owned by Arthur during his administration. No reputable historian seems to dispute the fact that he had no pets of any kind.

#2: Franklin Pierce (1853-1857) Most historians attest that not a single animal resided at the White House during Pierce’s tenure as president. History does indicate that Commodore Perry, following his return from Japan, did give two small dogs as gifts to the president. One of the dogs was believed to be given to Pierce’s friend, Jefferson Davis. The fate of the other is unknown.

#3: Millard Fillmore (1850-1853) Although he was named as a founding member of the Humane Society, history does not record any pets attributed to Fillmore. A member of the “Do Nothing” party, Fillmore’s decision to join the Humane Society may have been a political move. He is quoted as saying, “Nothing brings out the lower traits of human nature like office-seeking,” and it may have been true in his case.

#4: Andrew Johnson (1865-1869) Some historians believe that Johnson was an animal lover because of his fondness for mice. One record is that he left flour out at night for a family of mice scurrying around in his bedroom. Another attests that Johnson saved bread crumbs and water in a dish for the creatures.

Two thoughts come to mind. First, what better way to deter the rodents from occupying his bed than to leave out food for them? Second, this was reported during the darkest days of his impeachment and perhaps he was hoping the pests would multiply and annoy whoever succeeded him.

#5: James Knox Polk (1845-1949) Like presidents before and after him, Polk did not have any pets. History does record that he liked horses, but that is also common with many early presidents since there was no other convenient way to travel. Unlike other presidents, there is no record of Polk owning a dog or other animal, and no record of naming a horse like a pet.

#6: James Monroe (1817-1825) History records that a Spaniel named Buddy resided with Monroe for a time. The dog is believed to have belonged to Monroe’s daughter or granddaughter and not his pet.

#7: James Madison (1809-1817) Like the president who followed him, Madison had no pets of his own. His wife Dolley, did possess a green parrot named Polly.

#8: William Henry Harrison (1841) Although he died of pneumonia after being in office only one month, Harrison had two animals with him at the White House, a goat and a cow. Since it was common at that time to use goats or sheep to trim the lawn, and get fresh milk from cows, they cannot really be counted as pets.

#9: Harry S. Truman (1945-1953) Dogs seem to be among the most popular pets of most presidents, but that was not true about Truman. He preferred that his family be pet-free, but after his daughter Margaret begged for a dog, Truman gave in to her. It was an Irish Setter, but it didn’t stay long at the White House. After a short time, Truman gave the dog away, citing that Mike was often sick.

In 1947, Truman received another dog as a Christmas gift. Feller, a Cocker Spaniel, was given by a woman in Truman’s home state of Missouri. Since Truman did not want another dog at the White House, he gave the dog to his physician. When dog lovers around the country learned what had happened, they accused Truman of being anti-canine. Feller was then handed off to a Navy admiral. After a few more exchanges, the dog ended up living out his life on a farm in Ohio.

Copyright 2012 by S. R. Morris