just honest feedback, what does the reader get from this if anything? what works, what doesn't? use of words, image, flow etc. can anyone relate? does it capture how stressful christmas can be for mothers or is it just whingey? thanks!
My Review
Would you like to review this Poem? Login | Register
'Somebody someplace ~ is destroying ~ Jingle Bells ~ on a battered ~ old tinwhistle'
(I remember times like that!)
The first stanza is a really well expressed contrast from the second equally well put; both so appropriate for the time of year. You've simply but somehow poignantly created comfortable scenes then, gently blown them apart with those three last lines .. and, made me laugh aloud! Thank you.
Look forward to reading more of your writing very soon.
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
emma thanks for your comments. glad it made you laugh!
There's no mistaking the message, is there? ;-) I like that you've given the reader a few annotated snaps from the mental camera too. What is so odd, and I see it all the time here on WC, is that people seem to want to scrunch their lines into a tall, vertical pillar of words. Perhaps it's just me but I'm not sure why this is popular. I could read them just as well, perhaps a bit easier and with no loss of artistic rendering that I can see (other than the positioning on the paper/screen) if they were longer and a space between the lines or couplets. This gives the reader a chance to digest each thought; to help solidify the foundation that the succeeding lines are built upon. ..just a thought. I really liked it, especially the musical references and the writer's reactions to them. The last line is a nice way to gently close the door on all the visual cacophony too. "..some peace and quiet" :o)
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
thank you for reading and for your comments. i suppose i just like this layout and feel it looks rig.. read morethank you for reading and for your comments. i suppose i just like this layout and feel it looks right, but i do see what you mean about breaking it up a bit more and will consider that for again. thanks!
'Somebody someplace ~ is destroying ~ Jingle Bells ~ on a battered ~ old tinwhistle'
(I remember times like that!)
The first stanza is a really well expressed contrast from the second equally well put; both so appropriate for the time of year. You've simply but somehow poignantly created comfortable scenes then, gently blown them apart with those three last lines .. and, made me laugh aloud! Thank you.
Look forward to reading more of your writing very soon.
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
emma thanks for your comments. glad it made you laugh!
hi, i've been writing quite a while now, mostly poetry, though i also attempt the odd short story and am in the process of writing something longer too! i hope it will one day be a novel. i write to e.. more..