Ouch! Sure looks like you smote someone. Twenty years as a sailor may be sullying my interpretation of this, so if I've got it all wrong, I apologize.
Posted 10 Years Ago
10 Years Ago
On the contrary. I think those years of experience have enabled you to nail it perfectly!
Tha.. read moreOn the contrary. I think those years of experience have enabled you to nail it perfectly!
Thank you for the review.
There's plenty of walking wounded that never recover; both in war and love. But I've heard it said that all things are fair in either. And it does no good to argue with philosophy no matter what statistics one has at hand. (smile) I enjoyed the read.
Posted 11 Years Ago
11 Years Ago
I've heard the same, Fabian. And it's more true than not, I think. Thanks for the kind words. Gla.. read moreI've heard the same, Fabian. And it's more true than not, I think. Thanks for the kind words. Glad you enjoyed my work.
I'm a sucker for anything military, so this really resonated with me ;-) And then, of course, re-reading it, I dove a little deeper and found a lot of meaning in those depths. The narrator's "soldier" having little regard for authority says so much, and yet the confession that follows, that the writer is not in charge, makes me wonder who, in fact, has gone AWOL...I'm left wondering this further as I'm led to believe had the writer been in charge the soldier would have found himself kicked to the proverbial curb, thus granting him the purple heart and the honorary discharge.
I really like this piece.
As a nitpicky aside (there's always one *laugh* we've only just become acquainted, thanks to your friend, and mine, jacob...you'll get used to me, I promise) ;-) I couldn't help notice you're a retired English teacher. As such, and please forgive me if I'm wrong, don't you think the line "I’d much rather be writing the battle plan myself" might sound stronger as "I'd much rather write the battle plan myself"...eliminating "be" and the passive "ing"? Meh, just a thought ;-) It doesn't take much away from the write, which I thoroughly enjoyed.
Thank you so much for sharing this with us. I look forward to reading much more of your work in future!
-kimmer
Posted 11 Years Ago
11 Years Ago
Thank you so much for your in-depth review and interpretation of this piece. You're so right...ther.. read moreThank you so much for your in-depth review and interpretation of this piece. You're so right...there's so much going on in this piece and it's so gratifying that someone took the time to delve so deeply into it.
As for your observation about the technicality of the elimination of "to be" and passive tense...yes, you are absolutely correct. And no offense taken at all. It would be stronger, absolutely, but for some reason, I like the flow of the extra syllable in there....don't know why. I'm not a perfectionist, so I'm fine with it as is, especially since it does not affect the meaning of the piece. Your comments are much appreciated.....
~rubie
11 Years Ago
O.O Not a perfectionist?? Are there such people?? *laugh*
I'm technically a novelist.. read moreO.O Not a perfectionist?? Are there such people?? *laugh*
I'm technically a novelist; I bump my head sometimes and go all Editor on poetry when I least expect it ;-) I forget it's totally subjective, and, well, it's Mother's Day so...I may or may not have had a gin cocktail with my breakfast in bed xD
Life is so much a battle at times, and we rely on our fellow soldiers, often only to be abandoned. "I’d much rather be writing the battle plan myself..." If only we could... Great write!
i get two separate yet strangely similar trains of thought from this write. sure , it can easily be about abandonment and betrayal...that follows... and i also (having had the operation) read something else into this....shooting blanks....infertile. even worse, impotency. either way you slice it.. or choose to adopt both lines of reasoning to keep it interesting, this is a provocative and resonant piece of prose.
Thank you so much for such insightful comments. I have always been a firm believer that every reade.. read moreThank you so much for such insightful comments. I have always been a firm believer that every reader brings something unique to a piece as he or she reads it, depending on the background experience of that reader. That's why there is no "right" or "wrong" way to see a poem. It means something different to each reader. But I will tell you that both meanings crossed my mind as I wrote this. Thanks for your comments and your visit to my page. Both are much appreciated.
11 Years Ago
i like your writes so far. i shall return. and you are very welcome
11 Years Ago
Likewise. I love your style as well. And I shall likewise return to yours.
It`s scary being left - by accident or design - but fear is, though a natural reaction, a negative one. It takes some getting used to, but we use what recources we have to live with it while we regroup - and slowly, surely, we don`t notice it so much.
Thanks for sharing this, Rubie. P.
Posted 11 Years Ago
11 Years Ago
Thanks so much for the read, Pete. Yes, the rejection and fear we feel do often serve to strengthen.. read moreThanks so much for the read, Pete. Yes, the rejection and fear we feel do often serve to strengthen us, though it may not feel that way at first....
Interesting concept. We don't always have the luxury of being the General and writing the battle plan ourselves. It's difficult to be just thrown in to the wolves unprepared, but you learn to trust and just go with your survival instincts. Disconcerting yes, but it will make you a much tougher adversary in the long run.
Posted 11 Years Ago
11 Years Ago
Absolutely. It is only in the heat of battle that we learn survival skills. Thanks for the read an.. read moreAbsolutely. It is only in the heat of battle that we learn survival skills. Thanks for the read and the wonderful comment! :)
I am a retired high school English teacher from New Jersey where I've lived all my life, except for 4 years when I lived in Philadelphia in the mid 1970s.
I enjoy reading the work of other writer.. more..