I thought I would have a look at some of your writing, to see if I had anything intelligent to say about it to help you on your way with constructive critique.
I picked this from the top of your list.
My style of review can be long but it will always give the writer a notion of the impact it has made on me as one of their readers.
My review.
1) Structure: Highly unique. I am not sure whether to read it as a newspaper in columns or whether to read it by moving across the page left to right to left to right. More on this shortly in terms of meaning.
You choose not to rhyme. Nor is their any rhythm to the poem. But you do fully punctuate. Short of explaining the movements between verses, I would not call this so much free or blank verse but rather poetry in prose - that is words written in prose format with traits which resemble verse. I like the way you do this.
2) Use of English: Simple and accessible to all. It fits the piece.
3) Allusion: It would appear there is one large allusion cum metaphor running through this poem which is life or writing related to nature and the seasons. See more below.
4) Meaning: You leave the reader no clue a to the meaning of the poem other than your opening quote:
'Sometimes all we need to do is to take a step'
I repeat myself endlessly on this point, but it is worth saying it again to you Roopal. Meaning is for the writer to own. It is for the reader to guess or rather more importantly interpret in their own way.
Some poems can be quite transparent in their meaning. Yours is rather more opaque. That challenges the reader to read and read and read again, as I have just done. Both approaches have equal validity. I congratulate you on this challenge you set for the reader.
You clearly start with a paragraph (let's say it is poetry in prose) which is all about writing in such away as to make the reader (at least me) regard what follows as the poem created as a result. Writing as creation.
If you read it as columns rather than across the page, you get a slightly different take. But the last three stanzas cum paragraphs are the product of your writing.
I see three ways of looking at this:
a. A straight piece where you write a story following your first verse;
b. The story is an analogy for writing; the art of creation, where ideas are filling your head but you are blocked and need to sweep out the autumn leaves to write in a new and seasonally related spring related way; and
c. An analogy for for life be it in seasons or the everyday- out with the old of autumn and in with the new of spring. A new step forward by sheer will.
I see all as existing in your poem and related to your own words again: 'Sometimes all we need to do is to take a step' - a step forward in writing, in seasons and in life.
5) Impact and favourite lines:
I think the whole issue of the old and the new, be it in writing, or in nature, or in life will impact all. I found the way you expressed this neat in its own complexity of varying meanings.
To reach the new, you have to take a single step over the old and decaying to decayed.
Let me just list two of my favourite parts of this poetic prose:
First:
Your opening stanza.
She touched her pen and a prose was framed.
As she started to scribble,
The ink began to set her emotions free,
And a poem was born again.
Writing is an essential for those who write. Often it is the only mode of self-expression to clear one's head and explain oneself to oneself, what our life is, a moment of it and what it means.
Your first line admits to prose and you last to a poem. An indicator for poetry in pose style to follow.
Second:
Your closing stanza and the resolution of the piece.
The dead leaves of the autumn lying in the way,
Shivered by the thought of travelers stepping on them,
She stopped, she waited,
Spring wasn't far, it came, and the path unfolded.
Be it in writing, nature or life, one step is only needed to bring needed change.
6) Overview: A very unique structure well expressed in such a way as to generate alternative meanings for the reader.
I find this well written and look forward to reading more of your pieces in time.
With my warmest regards
James Hanna-Magill
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
Thank you so much. I am happy I could write something meaningful.
The structure I set .. read moreThank you so much. I am happy I could write something meaningful.
The structure I set while posting it was moving across the page left to right to left to right, but now when I see, I wonder how it seems ok while reading it in columns.
About the English part, because it is not my first language, I'm still working on it, but my main aim is to keep my grammar correct so I try not to overdo it. :)
The girl decides to take a step, and it is about her struggle, her observation of others struggle and how can someone else's step cause someone shiver. but in the end she finds her way out. In fact there is more to it than meets the eye. :)
I'm happy that you noticed both the words prose and poem, contradictory and yet in the same stanza.
My personal favorite line happens to be 'But the sparkle of her eyes was telling a different story,'. I'm happy you liked more than I expected.
I will keep trying and write better. Thanks for your useful review, all that an aspirant needs is encouragement and inspiration. :) :)
11 Years Ago
Thank you. You certainly have all of my encouragement, Your friend, James
just a query.. I really didnt understand the relation between the first paragraph and the other paragraphs -_- .. but its a nice poem nevertheless.
Posted 11 Years Ago
11 Years Ago
the main theme of the poem is 'taking a step'... the first stanza tells about a person who for the f.. read morethe main theme of the poem is 'taking a step'... the first stanza tells about a person who for the first time touched the pen and realized that he can write. from there the person is now willing to take steps, tough and hard steps.. so the next three paragraphs explain her ups and downs, her hard work and her will. and a writer, a traveler or any person can relate to. :)
happy that you asked, thanks for reading and complimenting. :) :)
11 Years Ago
just a random question ok.. do you love to travel??
11 Years Ago
yes. very much. :) why do you ask that?
11 Years Ago
I asked because I thought u would from the poem and the way u explained it to me :) .. I have a blog.. read moreI asked because I thought u would from the poem and the way u explained it to me :) .. I have a blog specially for travel ... I wish to travel the entire world :p.. just saying
11 Years Ago
wow... may i know the blog link... i might like it !!! :)