This is solemn and at times poetically profound with a great story to it. However, certain lines are rather wordy for the musicality to flow smoothly, and in some cases, there are grammar issues such as "And bringS you safely back to me" (because in the previous line, the "drown god" - I'm not sure what that's supposed to mean....Neptune? Poseidon? or "drownED God? - whatever the case, you say "....drown god is full of mercy" and therefore the hope in the second line is that he "brings". Watch out for those, for there are a few throughout the poem). Also, there are things (like the aforementioned "drown God") that don't quite make much sense in what exactly you're trying to say (others include: "Oh anon", "shines here"/there" (what are these places exactly?), "let the dark ominous water lessen his wrath"....how would that make sense to the story?). Furthermore, this appears to be a duet of sorts between the two lovers, but it's not quite as clear as to which lover is speaking in which stanza (especially since the stanzas are not of an even number, so we can't particularly follow along). This is not to say, tell us which one, but have each one speak a certain way so we are aware by how they're talking that it's the sailor or the lover speaking (you do it a bit by the "Do you ever wonder" lines (but we're not entirely sure who says those). This is a phenomenal start, don't get me wrong. I love the theme and the story, and how it's constructed, but with some tweaking to the musicality, some editing on the grammar, and some clarification as to who is who in the stanzas, this indeed would be a golden gem of poetry.
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
Looking at the poem again I have realized that I had made a lot of mistakes and I completely agree w.. read moreLooking at the poem again I have realized that I had made a lot of mistakes and I completely agree with you on all of those. Frankly I'm quite embarrassed with my poem now but yeah, I learned a lot from your review and I'm sure to watch out for those mistakes next time. I'm going to review the work and make the necessary changes. I am so happy to be able to learn a lot and receive such informative comments. I thank you so much for your effort and I appreciate every piece of advice you give. I hope I am able to improve my skills soon.
This is solemn and at times poetically profound with a great story to it. However, certain lines are rather wordy for the musicality to flow smoothly, and in some cases, there are grammar issues such as "And bringS you safely back to me" (because in the previous line, the "drown god" - I'm not sure what that's supposed to mean....Neptune? Poseidon? or "drownED God? - whatever the case, you say "....drown god is full of mercy" and therefore the hope in the second line is that he "brings". Watch out for those, for there are a few throughout the poem). Also, there are things (like the aforementioned "drown God") that don't quite make much sense in what exactly you're trying to say (others include: "Oh anon", "shines here"/there" (what are these places exactly?), "let the dark ominous water lessen his wrath"....how would that make sense to the story?). Furthermore, this appears to be a duet of sorts between the two lovers, but it's not quite as clear as to which lover is speaking in which stanza (especially since the stanzas are not of an even number, so we can't particularly follow along). This is not to say, tell us which one, but have each one speak a certain way so we are aware by how they're talking that it's the sailor or the lover speaking (you do it a bit by the "Do you ever wonder" lines (but we're not entirely sure who says those). This is a phenomenal start, don't get me wrong. I love the theme and the story, and how it's constructed, but with some tweaking to the musicality, some editing on the grammar, and some clarification as to who is who in the stanzas, this indeed would be a golden gem of poetry.
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
Looking at the poem again I have realized that I had made a lot of mistakes and I completely agree w.. read moreLooking at the poem again I have realized that I had made a lot of mistakes and I completely agree with you on all of those. Frankly I'm quite embarrassed with my poem now but yeah, I learned a lot from your review and I'm sure to watch out for those mistakes next time. I'm going to review the work and make the necessary changes. I am so happy to be able to learn a lot and receive such informative comments. I thank you so much for your effort and I appreciate every piece of advice you give. I hope I am able to improve my skills soon.
I am a college student who has a passion for writing (when I'm in the mood). I like to read an assortment of writing and genres but I am particularly attracted to the horror genre. I'm a big fan of St.. more..