i believe that there is. truth can have an ugliness but need not if viewed with a discerning eye. i've often thought that. there is a story in every tragedy that befalls us - the best part being overcoming a struggle or the beauty in accepting and overcoming. a stepping stone to bigger and better things. we just need to know how to look and where to look. matters of the heart are complex. the flip side of pain is beauty as you allude. outstanding, wonderful food for thought and reflection. deep stuff, well said ... :)
This feels like a modern & original way to make the age-old point about how there's a lesson in everything, even painful events. I like the way you are urging the reader to consider another viewpoint when considering heartache, rather than making this sound like a lecture where you are making critical remarks about people who become so ensnared by the pain that they don't see the bigger picture of such experiences. I like that this is a gentle reminder, not judgmental.
In regards to your author's note: I don't think you over-used the line "beauty in pain." I thought the repetition set in nicely and emphasized the theme.
What I like most about this piece is how vividly it captures beauty in life's darkest times. The metaphors and imagery are spot-on in not only conveying the point, but making the reader feel the words. The first stanza pulled me in and every stanza that followed kept me hooked. The last line is both true and powerful ... it gave a great final impression.
If I may critique, I don't think capitializing every line does this piece justice. I know it's a stylistic choice, but consider:
There is a beauty in pain
An art to the way the heart cracks
There are two ways one could read the lines above. In one way (the way you intended), the lines are read as if they're in the same sentence. In the other way, first line reads as a complete sentence and the second line reads as the start to a new sentence ... if that happens, the reader could stumble on the third line. With this critique in mind, the first stanza would read:
There is a beauty in pain,
an art to the way the heart cracks,
a never ending inspiration caused by falling tears
and quivering lips
Don't get me wrong, I didn't stumble as I read those lines, but a reader possibly could ... best to lessen that possibility as much as possible.
Another critique: In the third line of the third stanza, I suggest saying "the personal" for emphasis instead of "a personal."
Another critique: The line "but if we don't look for the beauty in pain" felt a bit chunky to me. A general rule of writing is to avoid the word "not" as much as possible, as in most cases, it's best to tell what things are, not what they aren't. That being said, something like "but if we ingore the beauty in pain" or "but blind to the beauty in pain" would be stronger in my opinion.
I know I spent a great deal of this review with critiques, but trust me, those parts of the poem weren't as distracting as the length of my critiques would suggest. I just felt like I had to explain my reasoning in detail.
- William Liston
Posted 7 Years Ago
7 Years Ago
Thank you so much, I've always loved constructed criticism. I knew this piece needed work, I just ne.. read moreThank you so much, I've always loved constructed criticism. I knew this piece needed work, I just needed help finding out how :) I'll look forward to revising it and making it better with the help of your critiques. Thank you William.
Are you searching for purpose?
Then write something, yeah it might be worthless
Then paint something, then it might be wordless
Pointless curses, nonsense verses
You'll see purpose start to surfac.. more..