Hi Kathleen:
This poem has potential -- but I didn't find the emotional courage here that I did with "I am a Writer." You give us detached observation rather than taking a leap into how you feel about your mother being sick and not recognizing you. "I am a Writer" took chances and I felt the anger battering its way through my computer screen. But here I can't feel the sadness or the anger, I'd expect in this type of piece.
You need to give us some details -- specifics to make it yours. Otherwise, it feels like your skating on the surface without exploring any new ground. Insert some of the energy and emotion from "I am a Writer" here and you'll get a more powerful piece.
Wow. I'm in shock. This is stunning, simply stunning. I think it's the (2nd?) best piece I've ever read on this site - and, believe me, that's quite an accomplishment.
You seperate stanzas in the perfect places - you choose the right, fragile wording - you convey emotion through your simple imagery - you let the reader choose the outcome, making the experience more personal - your use of repetition is amazing! I'm just...in...shock.
I can't believe you've only been writing for a month - you're much too good so soon!
I love:
"she smiles
she sees now
sister, friend, mother, daughter, stranger
no matter
she does not know who I am"
It's so simple, so direct...the reader doesn't even get to know who it is, but the beauty is that it doesn't matter!
And the "patient / scream" stanza is perfectly spaced, pulling the reader along and using an emotional pull toward anxiety that you must have felt at this moment.
Maybe I'm over-analyzing at this point, but I really do love this piece, and I'm going to put it in my library right away!
What an awesome piece. Visiting ones parents or grandparents can bring back memories and frustrations - memories to be found, frustrations from not being able to connect.
I remember visiting my mother. I seemed to be the only one she really remembered, many times we'd recall funny times of the past. Then I'd leave - feeling so very guilty!
You approached a very touch subject in a very nice manner. It brought back many memories.
i'm not a writer. my poems are a way of channeling my emotions out on paper. i don't even know if they should be called poems, you decide. I put the words down as they evolve in my head so i don't us.. more..