Comic book Ideas

I would really appreciate It if you guys could tell me which Idea is the one you like most also give It a rank between 1-5.

Idea 1- A boy saves battles Supernatural foes to protect his word.

Idea 2- A evil lunatic struggles to rule the world with his clones conspiring against him.

Idea 3- A new species of human is created resulting with each new human wanting to become the strongest.

Idea 4 - A scientist explores the world of emotions resulting in his emotions manifesting themselves into humans.

Idea 5-  A Monk must abandon his family to become something much more powerful.

Idea 6- A boys over active imagination put in play in his notebook where he doodles.

Idea 7 - As children we all drew stick figures then gradually moved on the comic books but now these stick figures want pay back on all the super heroes who stole there beloved children away.

Author's Note

I would really appreciate It if you guys could tell me which Idea is the one you like most also give *each* Idea It's own rank between 1-5.

Example 1. I say Idea 1 Is good and i give it 4 out of five and IDEA 4 is the one I like most.

Reviews

[Delmar Cooper]

They all inhale, but the one taking the shallowest breath is number four. Generating people from raw emotion has an appeal. Supposedly two people generate a third person from the emotion of love or at least passion, but this mad scientist can conjure up a being by getting the fish sandwich instead of the Big Mac at the drive through. Lots of possibilities there.

[Berniemacsgreatesthi]

Thanks for replying !

[Coyote Poetry]

Nice outline for story. Good to outline your writing and goal. Give you a place to head and end.
Coyote

[David Jae]

Idea 1: Okay. 2/5 Fairly standard idea. Would depend on the strength of your protagonist/antagonist to make it stand out.

Idea 2: Good. 3/5. Nice idea, but don't have an evil lunatic. That robs your antagonist of all responsibility and makes him too cliched. Give him some characteristics that can make him somewhat understandable as to why he acts the way he does.

Idea 3: Good 3/5. Nice idea, but you will need to be clear what the path of the story will be.

Idea 4: Okay. 2/5. Interesting, but you will need to know what the threat is.

Idea 5: Weak. 1/5

Idea 6: Weak. 1/5

Idea 7: Okay. 2/5

Ideas 2 and 3 are the strongest, in my opinion. In fact, you might combine the two.

Hope that helps.