Your poem verges on a lot of abstraction, which is usually good in moderation. I think that you have a wonderful idea with this poem, and I suggest that you explore each line poetically. For example, with the first line, maybe describe how it changed the stranger's day? Unless...are the lines that follow the first line describing how it can change a stranger's day for the better? It's a little vague and abstract, meaning that I can't visualize it, and that every reader will have a different interpretation of each line. Maybe add some descriptive imagery that accompanies the lines, to clarify it a bit more? Again, it's a really interesting concept, I like it a lot!
One line I think is distracting to the poem is the 7th line (or second stanza). I don't really see how that ties in with the rest of the poem, where the speaker is saying what she/he believes in.
The only other criticism I have with this poem are the line breaks. Some lines are really long, and that's a mouthful. One way some of my colleagues have told me to deal with line breaks in poetry is to break the line naturally. For example, if a poem starts off like, "There was a bear in the woods and he had thorns in his eyes," the line is a little too long. A natural way to cut the line would be (slashes indicate line breaks), "There was a bear in the woods / and he had thorns in his eyes." When you read the poem out loud, and you find yourself pausing mid-line, that's usually a sign that there should be a line break.
Anyway, again, I really like the concept of the poem! I think you have a lot of potential!
Thank you for the constructive criticism! I really appreciate it. This was a poem I had to write for.. read moreThank you for the constructive criticism! I really appreciate it. This was a poem I had to write for poetry class where I had to follow a certain form. I will definitely take your tips into consideration for my future writings. Thanks again!
8 Years Ago
Not a problem! I hope it helped! Ahh, forms are difficult to do well, especially when it's a prompt .. read moreNot a problem! I hope it helped! Ahh, forms are difficult to do well, especially when it's a prompt for a class! They're the worst, haha, in my opinion. You're welcome! Have a good day!
8 Years Ago
Haha for me, the difficulty depends on the form. I like some but others, like sonnets, are awful! Th.. read moreHaha for me, the difficulty depends on the form. I like some but others, like sonnets, are awful! Thank you, you as well!
Your poem verges on a lot of abstraction, which is usually good in moderation. I think that you have a wonderful idea with this poem, and I suggest that you explore each line poetically. For example, with the first line, maybe describe how it changed the stranger's day? Unless...are the lines that follow the first line describing how it can change a stranger's day for the better? It's a little vague and abstract, meaning that I can't visualize it, and that every reader will have a different interpretation of each line. Maybe add some descriptive imagery that accompanies the lines, to clarify it a bit more? Again, it's a really interesting concept, I like it a lot!
One line I think is distracting to the poem is the 7th line (or second stanza). I don't really see how that ties in with the rest of the poem, where the speaker is saying what she/he believes in.
The only other criticism I have with this poem are the line breaks. Some lines are really long, and that's a mouthful. One way some of my colleagues have told me to deal with line breaks in poetry is to break the line naturally. For example, if a poem starts off like, "There was a bear in the woods and he had thorns in his eyes," the line is a little too long. A natural way to cut the line would be (slashes indicate line breaks), "There was a bear in the woods / and he had thorns in his eyes." When you read the poem out loud, and you find yourself pausing mid-line, that's usually a sign that there should be a line break.
Anyway, again, I really like the concept of the poem! I think you have a lot of potential!
Thank you for the constructive criticism! I really appreciate it. This was a poem I had to write for.. read moreThank you for the constructive criticism! I really appreciate it. This was a poem I had to write for poetry class where I had to follow a certain form. I will definitely take your tips into consideration for my future writings. Thanks again!
8 Years Ago
Not a problem! I hope it helped! Ahh, forms are difficult to do well, especially when it's a prompt .. read moreNot a problem! I hope it helped! Ahh, forms are difficult to do well, especially when it's a prompt for a class! They're the worst, haha, in my opinion. You're welcome! Have a good day!
8 Years Ago
Haha for me, the difficulty depends on the form. I like some but others, like sonnets, are awful! Th.. read moreHaha for me, the difficulty depends on the form. I like some but others, like sonnets, are awful! Thank you, you as well!
I'm a senior in high school. I have taken poetry and creative writing classes. Next year I am going tocolleger to study communications, a focus in possibly journalism, and a minor in creative writing. more..