I think this is brilliant! poetic critique of art and very well done, no matter what some say, if you know who I mean, ;) Poetry is art not a novel, I thought it was just as moving as the movement in the artwork. you have a good eye for interpretation for art and putting into your own art.
Posted 2 Years Ago
2 Years Ago
Patricia, thank you! I was proud of this piece and then you know who put it down. then, I was sure a.. read morePatricia, thank you! I was proud of this piece and then you know who put it down. then, I was sure about it!
It’s a good read, but there are some grammar issues that you could work on when you have time othe.. read moreIt’s a good read, but there are some grammar issues that you could work on when you have time other than that I really enjoyed it. Keep writing! And don’t feel bad about grammar, I make mistakes all the time but they do interrupt the flow of the read but we all have done that.
"Each day is a day for renewal
Breathe in the freshness"
It makes total sense & your colors & descriptions are so on-point for the emotions. Beautiful painting also. "Life brings many shades of emotions"-yes, so true. Beautifully written poem.
I love the way you used colors to describe emotional states, black, red, blue, gray, and finally yellow as emergence of freedom….very imaginative, and for me as a painter, I can appreciate it so much.
Perfect imagery using these hues.
Best, Betty
Well, you did ask for feedback, so you can blame yourself for this.
First, dump the pictures. It’s a poem. If the words don’t move the reader, the picture won’t change that.
That aside, you face two problems that tend to be invisible to the author, because you cheat. When you read, you have two things the reader lacks: Context and intent. And if the reader lacks context as they read the words, you lose them, because there is no second first-impression. That’s why we need to do our editing from the seat of the reader, who arrives as a blank slate.
A second thing I see in all your work is that at all times you’re talking TO the reader, explaining and reporting. But that’s a nonfiction approach to writing—the one we’re taught in our school years, as they ready us for the needs of employers. And since employers, in general, want us to write reports, papers, and letters, most of our assignments are for reports and essays, which are fact-based and author-centric, as is your writing. But the goal of nonfiction is to inform. Poetry’s goal is to move the reader, emotionally—to make them care and feel. We don’t tell the reader, “I cried at my mother’s funeral,” for example. Our goal is to make the reader weep. And that requires an emotion-based approach. As E. L. Doctorow put it: “Good writing is supposed to evoke sensation in the reader. Not the fact that it’s raining, but the feeling of being rained upon.”
Look at your opening as a reader must:
• Sadness fade in a dark black hole
What can a reader say in response to this line but “Huh? What dark hole? And why is it fading, not getting worse. And, ‘fade,’ not ‘fades?’ ”
• Tearstain face crestfallen from despair
I give up? What’s a “tearstain face?” And why is it not “tearstained?”
Basically, you’re talking about a situation for which the reader has no context. Who is it about, and what happened? Where are we? When are we? What’s the backstory that resulted in the words? You know. But the reader? Not a clue.
There’s a LOT to writing poetry that’s not obvious, but is worth looking into. Mary Oliver wrote a really good book on the subject: A Poetry Handbook. And the excerpt for Stephen Fry’s, The Ode Less Traveled, on Amazon has some things to say about the flow of language that every writer should know.
Another great resource is the Shmoop site. They have lots of great work there, analyzed to show why and how it worked so well. Just hit, Student, and then, use the button to the left of the mid-page search window to select Poetry.
So…I know this isn’t what you hoped to hear, but since it’s not a matter of talent or how well you write, and we’ll never address the problem we don’t see as being one, I thought you might want to know. And....you did ask.
Hang in there, and keep on writing.
Jay Greenstein
https://jaygreenstein.wordpress.com/category/the-craft-of-writing/the-grumpy-old-writing-coach/
Why not? Is everyone the same. Must everyone fall in.. read more• Why do people love it then?
Why not? Is everyone the same. Must everyone fall into line?
You didn’t disagree with what I said about the use of pictures. You didn’t disagree with the idea that it’s better to invite the reader in, rather than talking to them. You just feel that if some people like the words I must praise it, too?
I’ve never been a follower. And, I assume that if we all express our views, the author is smart enough to make their own evaluation of what fits their situation.
Why? We learn nothing from those who agree with us.
Very well written with vivid imagery! Love these lines...( Each day is a day for renewal Breathe in the freshness Lift off the stress As emotion bleeds in color) A beautifully positive ending to this write. ~Sharon
I agree my dear friend.
"Each day is a day for renewal
Breathe in the freshness
Lift off the stress
As emotion bleeds in color"
We do change color. I believe we can control. Years ago. I was told I was black in spirit and I had to re-shape my life and thoughts. Anger is dark and love is hazel-green, maybe ocean blue. Thank you for sharing the amazing poetry and your thoughts.
Coyote
check out! www.facebook.com/twinoneandtwintwo
Hello writercafe friends. I've been on this site for a few years! I stopped writing for a while, and trying to get back into it! When I joined this sit.. more..