As always, Travis, your poetry is wonderful (I've been avoiding taking my literary vivisectionist's knife to your fiction, but I'll get to it).
I like the premise of this poem. I've been good at what I call objective listening all my life. I like a story, any story. Over the years, I've listened hungrily, gathering the bones of humanity, later to be reassembled with renewed flesh.
I've said: I have many story to tell of my life, some of which have actually happened.
Just the other day, I was pondering the six billion people in the world -- six billion people. And, I thought what it would be like to sit with each and listen to a story. Everyone has a story, and for those stories not so interesting, that's where we come in, the storyteller.
If you get time, check out my short story: Randy Joyce Locke (http://www.writerscafe.org/writing/KarlKlein/216753/)
I always try to mention hobos and bums and men of the sort when I can/when it's appropriate. I feel like they all have a story to tell, something worth sitting down to listen to, however terrible and unfortunate. Exponentially better than the crap we hear on tv and popular media these days..
Travis, you're a great writer! I am glad that i have the oppourtunity to read your work! I hope you will be able to share it with others, besides this website. I enjoyed this poem alot!
No trips, I think it's a wonderful idea, to find one who you could tell the story of. It's compassionate and is steeped with the possibility of historical mystery's
Not a grumpy old man I hope for your sakes
I thought that line 2 was a lil repetitive with gray
What is 'long and torn like light wiry white strands' referencing?
He has strands of white that run thru the beard
The questions start out as general questions then you are asking him
then back again cause you didn't ask him, right
'Seranly Grey', Yeah that's a nice one, Nice read
J.P.O.et
Honestly, this flows very nicely. A bit too nicely... Like a leave on a stream, I was pulled along by the current of this. Your form works well too. It's a bit like seeing it through the speaker's eyes. Thoughts occur in this manner; we don't think linearly or in perfect stanzas all the time. So having varied stanzas work very well here. I was also caught in the imagery of this. I could identify; I've looked at people and wondered about their story. I work with the public, so I come into contact with many people every day. Sometimes, I know their story; they are my regular customers and we talk about our lives. But with other people, I can only guess. For instance, why would a mother force her child to steal? These are the things we wonder about.
Your poem is wonderful... honestly. I loved diving in and taking a walk around in it.
I was a little lost at first, but I found my ground, the description of the man at the beginning, I think it was, I might have been off in my head, but that was confusing cause then there were no other descriptions of people, it seemed out of place with the rest. I like though how it takes something that we all think of, I wonder what would happen if I talked to that person, and well talked about. Good job
Deep...like a think-piece... I like it a lot and I've re-read it a couple of times to kind of...take it all in. It really is great. It makes me wonder all about this Grey person of whom you speak..was his story interesting?.. Can I ask if it is based on...someone in particular or was it just an idea conjured by some image? Or perhaps you're just wonderfully creative like that.
I have a comment about a comment a few places below me...I understand that reviews such as these are mostly opinion based and they said that the repetition of words 'doesn't hold the power that it can have' but I must disagree...I think it emphasizes what it is that you are trying to say. That is just my opinion though..I am a bit of a fan of repetitions.........
I mean no offence. I only offer my opinions with helpful, if you wish them to be, suggestions.
I'd like to let you know the idea behind this poem is fabulous. However, I just finally understood what that student teacher of mine has been talking about. She's always telling us not to be so wordy. You, Travis, have just done that. You placed too many wonderfully descriptive words into your poem, and it took away from the poem's potential strength. I know it's what you wanted, but it is up to you to fix it. I can be wordy too, but sometimes it just seems to fit to me.
Here are a few other things I noticed.
the one who walks by grayish like his scruffy gray beard,[don't repeat gray]
the bluey[?]
Please tell me so I can story tell
like you write through my eyes,
[it's not a smooth read through. i have to think a little bit to get the rhythm down right...]
I will see someone
like Grey is like, [the usage of like twice in one line does not hold the power it can have.]
-Kristin
Posted 16 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
awwwwww I really like this, it's just sort of a free flowed thought, and a very interesting one at that :) and in reply to your authors note- yes the questions do really work, it was the first thing I was going to comment on- I like them as though they're pausing thoughts/questions in the story, can't quote explain it, but either way- it works for me! :). And I don't think anything really tripped me up to be quite honest, the whole thing just sounds like awed intrigue as to where this stranger has been- and good for you if you actually want to do this one day! Sometimes taking an interest in other peoples stories is what makes them worth telling :) Well Done :) xx
I'm a 29-year-old using this site to backup my writings, which are mostly poems.
Leave a comment if you like, they always make me smile.
Have a nice day! more..