Uhh...me? You're in love with ME? Was that you peering through the window last night? 😆
Seriously, my point is, what's in it for the reader, emotionally? Someone we know not the smallest thing about is talking to someone not introduced, pleased over undefined situations and events. Don't tell the reader you're in love with the mystery person, of undefined age, gender, etc. Make the READER fall in love, for the reasons the protagonist did.
Poetry and fiction, unlike nonfiction, are emotion-based. Using the techniques of fiction that we're given in school we talk TO the reader—TELLING. But using the emotion based approach we involve the reader emotionally, by SHOWING them the world as-the-protagonist-experiences-it. We make them care, and feel, not just be well informed.
Make sense?
If so, take a trip to the Shmoop site. Once there, hit Student. Then, via the small button to the left of the search window (midpage), select Poetry. There are many great poems there, analyzed deeply, to show why, and how they work. It's a great look at the techniques that makes the masters what they are. And as Wilson Mizner put it: “If you steal from one author it’s plagiarism; if you steal from many it’s research.” So do a bit of research .
Not what you were hoping to hear, I know. But because you're emotionally involved with the work it will alway works for you, and you won't see it as a reader. So I thought you might want to know.
Hang in there, and keep on writing.
Jay Greenstein
https://jaygreenstein.wordpress.com/category/the-craft-of-writing/the-grumpy-old-writing-coach
Don-t need the lecture, thank you, for a piece I wrote FOR someone in another language and translate.. read moreDon-t need the lecture, thank you, for a piece I wrote FOR someone in another language and translated into English to share here. You missed the point. Further, you come across as extremely arrogant. I also have been writing for almost 40 years and have several publushed books and book contracts. I teach writing in 2 languages and at this stage in my life, I write whatever the f**k I want to. Have a nice night. If you do not like my work, find an author you do like.
2 Years Ago
• You missed the point
No, you did, I'm afraid. You've fallen into the trap that Da.. read more• You missed the point
No, you did, I'm afraid. You've fallen into the trap that David Sedaris mentioned: “The returning student had recently come through a difficult divorce, and because her pain was significant, she wrongly insisted her writing was significant as well.”
You took comments on this poem, as it stands on this day, as an attack you, personally—a trait most of us lose with maturity.
You wrote something meaningful only to someone else, yet believe that all the world will love your words, simply because you posted it. And you call ME arrogant?
Someone you don't know took time they didn't have to give you, to provide feedback YOU asked for by leaving the comments window open. Reacting with pique is scarcely an adult response.
And as a not so minor point, "Several publishing contracts?" Seriously? I looked. Self-publishing does NOT count as having a publishing contract. And, to brag about having self-published, you need a far better rating on Amazon than 6 or 7 million from being number one. ANYONE can self publish...even me. Bragging about self-publishing is like claiming to be a great lover after visiting a w***e.
Had you included a notice: "Praise only," I'd have passed by with no comment. But since you didn't:
If you want better critiques, post better writing. It's that simple.
2 Years Ago
I really do not care what you think of me. I do no put up with being harrassed and having my life th.. read moreI really do not care what you think of me. I do no put up with being harrassed and having my life threatened every day IRL, to be harassed here as well. I went through that a few years back, and there is a reason I am not very active on this site any more. I am sure some others appreciate your superiority. Goodbye from me,
I too believe we radiate when we are in love. A glow almost similar to that of a woman with child. It can be seen and felt in nuance when around those stricken deep with love. It is the fabric of the heart that weaves hope.
Bilingual (English and Spanish) poet, essayist, novelist, grant writer, editor, and technical writer working in Central America.
"A poet's work is to name the unnameable, to point at frauds, to ta.. more..