Hellen and Paul met on a pier one summer's day. Their paths kept crossing for three years, until Hellen moved back to the city. They met again a decade later. They'd never spoken a word between them.
This is something different for me, a mix of real-life and fiction... The entire relationship is based on looks and thoughts passing between two people. (In italics) They never speak a word, as circumstances get in the way each time. Would you read on? Be honest! (Sorry about the different colours, I coudn't change the font enough on here to distinguish between the two main characters.)
My Review
Would you like to review this Book? Login | Register
Since I rarely write prose, and when I do it's nothing alike, I cannot help you with the structure: if it wasn't in two colours it would be a little confusing, especially the mental interactions. However, I concluded that it does not matter who said what, because they are having the same thoughts! The last mental interaction is perfectly clear.
The style is alright as well. Nothing to add there.
Since you asked the question "would you read on?", here is what I think: depends.
The shortness of the narrative and the lack of a more developed story fits the sporadic meetings of the protagonists and the mental interactions. The story breaks in the end, leaving it in a cliffhanger. Though I can imagine there are people that like closure, I am perfectly fine with it, because I do the same in my writings. Leaving it as it is, means showing a glimpse of what is happening everyday and what will continue to happen in different ways. In other words, the short structure fits the story.
On the other hand, curiosity and imagination are set to work anyway, so if you're not going to continue it, my heart and mind might. So it is a story that you can leave alone like this, or continue it.
So, to answer your question simply: yes I would read on, but I would be perfectly satisfied with how it is.
I really enjoyed the story as it is something that happens quite often, and it kind of happened to me as well (I wrote it in the poem Cicada's Nights, part real-life and part fiction), so I can relate to those feelings and troubles. You pictured really well the problems of liking and seeing someone often and not talking to them. The friends of the protagonists in the story emphasise the continuing distraction that keeps them from interacting, especially acting, and that reflects well real life situations.
Thanks Stefano, I didn't exrect you to take the time to read, as it is different to anything I have .. read moreThanks Stefano, I didn't exrect you to take the time to read, as it is different to anything I have spoken about that has caught your attention. I have the whole story in my head as I lived the beginning of it, ie 3 years of meeting someone odd occassions and sharing these look/thought moments but never exchanging a word. It FELT like it should remain that way, that to speak would 'spoil' it and turn it into just another thing. I wrote a poem about it too, Man With A Dog. I'm not a love story kind of writer (or reader) but 'something' steered me to write that prologue so I wondered what other people thought as to whether I should cotinue writing... Much appreciated critique as always!
8 Years Ago
Actually, I randomly pick what I read, and if I have some thoughts on the matter I write them down.<.. read moreActually, I randomly pick what I read, and if I have some thoughts on the matter I write them down.
I agree that talking would spoil the story, but be warned: if continued that way it might become repetitive and boring. This depends on how long it will be. If you continue the story by tripling the number of words there are now, I think there will be no problems at all. However, the longer it gets the greater the chance of being repetitive. This is the reason why I said I am perfectly fine as it is, with a cliffhanger.
I am not sure what you mean with love story writer/reader. Did you mean the cases where romance is the primary genre of the novel/story/poem?
8 Years Ago
If I follow it as it happened, it won't be boring as other stories are intertwined... I've just uplo.. read moreIf I follow it as it happened, it won't be boring as other stories are intertwined... I've just uploaded the beginning, and this is exactly as it happened (from my pov of course). Just trying to fix the book up as it somehow ended up separate from the prologue. I suck at technical stuff lol.
Haha never submitted a review on my own work but I couldn't stand the two-colour thing going on so I had a sleep on it and woke four hours later with this... I like it better. I feel more comfortable continuing with it now. Hope you guys agree!
Let me know if it is more difficult to follow?
Since I rarely write prose, and when I do it's nothing alike, I cannot help you with the structure: if it wasn't in two colours it would be a little confusing, especially the mental interactions. However, I concluded that it does not matter who said what, because they are having the same thoughts! The last mental interaction is perfectly clear.
The style is alright as well. Nothing to add there.
Since you asked the question "would you read on?", here is what I think: depends.
The shortness of the narrative and the lack of a more developed story fits the sporadic meetings of the protagonists and the mental interactions. The story breaks in the end, leaving it in a cliffhanger. Though I can imagine there are people that like closure, I am perfectly fine with it, because I do the same in my writings. Leaving it as it is, means showing a glimpse of what is happening everyday and what will continue to happen in different ways. In other words, the short structure fits the story.
On the other hand, curiosity and imagination are set to work anyway, so if you're not going to continue it, my heart and mind might. So it is a story that you can leave alone like this, or continue it.
So, to answer your question simply: yes I would read on, but I would be perfectly satisfied with how it is.
I really enjoyed the story as it is something that happens quite often, and it kind of happened to me as well (I wrote it in the poem Cicada's Nights, part real-life and part fiction), so I can relate to those feelings and troubles. You pictured really well the problems of liking and seeing someone often and not talking to them. The friends of the protagonists in the story emphasise the continuing distraction that keeps them from interacting, especially acting, and that reflects well real life situations.
Thanks Stefano, I didn't exrect you to take the time to read, as it is different to anything I have .. read moreThanks Stefano, I didn't exrect you to take the time to read, as it is different to anything I have spoken about that has caught your attention. I have the whole story in my head as I lived the beginning of it, ie 3 years of meeting someone odd occassions and sharing these look/thought moments but never exchanging a word. It FELT like it should remain that way, that to speak would 'spoil' it and turn it into just another thing. I wrote a poem about it too, Man With A Dog. I'm not a love story kind of writer (or reader) but 'something' steered me to write that prologue so I wondered what other people thought as to whether I should cotinue writing... Much appreciated critique as always!
8 Years Ago
Actually, I randomly pick what I read, and if I have some thoughts on the matter I write them down.<.. read moreActually, I randomly pick what I read, and if I have some thoughts on the matter I write them down.
I agree that talking would spoil the story, but be warned: if continued that way it might become repetitive and boring. This depends on how long it will be. If you continue the story by tripling the number of words there are now, I think there will be no problems at all. However, the longer it gets the greater the chance of being repetitive. This is the reason why I said I am perfectly fine as it is, with a cliffhanger.
I am not sure what you mean with love story writer/reader. Did you mean the cases where romance is the primary genre of the novel/story/poem?
8 Years Ago
If I follow it as it happened, it won't be boring as other stories are intertwined... I've just uplo.. read moreIf I follow it as it happened, it won't be boring as other stories are intertwined... I've just uploaded the beginning, and this is exactly as it happened (from my pov of course). Just trying to fix the book up as it somehow ended up separate from the prologue. I suck at technical stuff lol.
Hello from downunder! I am one of those people who can just sit and write. It's like breathing for me. I've never shared and never published. It was my thing, my escape, my therapy...
I have two so.. more..