I love the flow (apparently there's been an edit, but I can't imagine you changed it too much). I like the way you turned the last stanza around in repetition.
I like how the roots taste soil instead of light, and as you describe it, it's like you're telling each other a story. Similarly, you further, and perhaps more subtly and powerfully, express a subtle disconnection with the outside world as you connect the reader with time when you describe veins/colors. It's an interesting contrast you create between fantasy/reality and history/moment(s) in time. Very interesting to read, thank you.
Posted 12 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
12 Years Ago
I think the last line of the debated stanza needs the word "ask" needs to be "asking", or another "a.. read moreI think the last line of the debated stanza needs the word "ask" needs to be "asking", or another "and" thrown in there for it to make sense grammatically, unless I'm reading it wrong..I'd hate to think we're debating everything but the relevant, LOL
Is the title in french?! Je l'ai adoré ! Trés bien !
The poem is original, pituresque and even a little naive at some points ... so basically I said: I loved it, I loved it, I loved it especially at some points =D
Still didn't get the metaphor, though :( Maybe I'm just too tired to think properly xD
Great job !
yes, the title is french. My family is french on my dad's side so I try to connect to that part of .. read moreyes, the title is french. My family is french on my dad's side so I try to connect to that part of my heritage, lame but ya lol It means 'the tree'
12 Years Ago
keep on trying, French is such a beautiful language !! On peut parler français s'il te plait !
In poetry writing (and I imagine in prose writing also) you find a word, or idea or
theme and come back to it, just not too often. Dickenson did it, so did Auden,
Plath, Eliot, Pound, Cummings, Stevens, Oats, Baraka, Giovanni, etc. In post
modernism it's so very easy to do but in blank verse, so easy to stray away from.
You have mastered it here.
Your October heart makes reasonable everything else that follows here; trees and blooms and tastes and colors and whispers all follow the theme of, and certainly
in October, more aplomb. This is good work and thanks so much for sharing it.
hder.
This is one of the best poems I've read in quite a while. Your metaphors are exquisite and so artfully done. I agree, the comma should stay, though it's hard to believe such drama would occur here over one little punctuation mark. It just goes to show how important that mark is.
If this wasn't on the featured poems page it should have been. IMHO.
BTW it's going into my favorites.
Posted 12 Years Ago
12 Years Ago
I'm glad you found it likeable enough to go in your favorites. I don't know if it was featured... n.. read moreI'm glad you found it likeable enough to go in your favorites. I don't know if it was featured... not really sure how that works.
12 Years Ago
To tell you the truth neither am I but I think it has to do with a certain number of reads and revie.. read moreTo tell you the truth neither am I but I think it has to do with a certain number of reads and reviews within a short amount of time. I'm telling others about this poem. It's amazing.
those first three lines are magic, but you know that, they grab my heart and pull me closer
the trembling, whispering words steal my imagination and i am ready to run away to the land of L'arbre, anywhere, just to get nearer those words
and then the story of the child, it needs a pause, it is important for us to linger there a little, i might question its', it is the only thing i would question this far
My tree, not just some random, arbitrary living organism with limbs and leaves, but this tree that belongs to my heart . . . and then those amazing last two lines
not much in the way of review, these words grabbed me tighter than any single work I've read today, and that's saying something
Beautiful, truly beautiful. I speaks to my mind and also to my heart. One of my favorites from yours. It does not to be criticized, but I will be sincere. I think it needs a more powerful final, in order to maintain the higher tension you achieved in the rest. I understood your need to express that idea once again, my humble opinion is that it would have been better without.
Posted 12 Years Ago
12 Years Ago
you are so polite lol thank you for your suggestion :)
Beautiful poem ... punctuation optional ... there is a wonderful sense of the child returning home and finding an old friend ... one that can create its own colors and is willing to listen to words you would not share with another. There is a sense of innocence woven into your words ... one that recalls the time of our on innocence.
This is cool. I gotta admit, trees do have a mysterious power to them; they live longer than any human can, and they preside over their grounds and witness things men never will. You always have to wonder if they can hear you when you speak to them . . . it's a little comforting to think they can.
I graduated with my B.A. in English (emphasis creative writing) My ultimate goal is to be the U.S. Poet Laureate and to be a college professor of poetry. I'm a wildflower with a poetic soul. I'm als.. more..