Closures in life are so important. But no matter how hard we try, this is something we can never achieve or perhaps we don't want to. The 'Last Goodbye' is an underlying feeling which just stays with us, not to be spoken.
This piece portrays that to me in a subtle way. Very nicely done. Loved it ! :)
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
I completely second you on that note Ali! Thank you for such an insightful and warm feedback :)
I enjoyed this piece ... it really captured the pain of having to say goodbye. The imagery was nice and created a melancholic mood quite well ... I love it when a poet uses imagery to set the tone of the piece. I especially enjoyed the lines "When my laughter swoons / And the tears go dry" ... something about the simplicity and sorrow in those lines struck me.
Along with the emotional aspect, this piece shows considerable skill too. The rhyme and flow seem natural (for the most part) and not forced, which is difficult to achieve, but nonetheless, you've seemingly made this piece "dance" with ease. If I may critique, I think there are some changes you could make to improve the flow. These aren't really shortcomings on the poem itself; they're just things I would've done differently (that you may or may not find beneficial).
For example, I think the phrase "begins to" in the second line should be deleted because it's unnecessary to the meaning and (for me) it disrupts the flow. Also, in the fifth line, I would say "When the GRAY sky roars..." for me, inserting the word "gray" would give this piece a better rhythmical feel.
I would write the fourth stanza as follows:
When the WEAKENED body embraces the crust,
And a FRAIL existence turns to dust,
In my opinion, the words "weakened" and "frail" help to convey the sorrowful mood, and they also benefit the flow.
Hope you found this helpful. Please make changes to this piece at your own judgement.
- William Liston
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
Firstly a heartiest thanks to you William for such a helpful and encouraging review. I appreciate th.. read moreFirstly a heartiest thanks to you William for such a helpful and encouraging review. I appreciate the criticisms more than the praises. Makes me feel your humble involvement into my poetry! I have made the specified change in the second line since I absolutely agree with you on the fact that it disrupts the flow,so I can do without it. For the fourth stanza I feel death doesn't always come with old age and/or a disease. Sometimes it comes without the slightest hint. Hence I wanted to keep that essence of uncertainty. But I love and completely appreciate your perspective and creativity towards uplifting my poetry. It sounds beautiful the way you described it-" When the WEAKENED body embraces the crust,And a FRAIL existence turns to dust,". Cannot thank you enough for this amazing and warm feedback :)
The words flowed along with a lovely dignity and celebration, somehow, of the passing of life and the remembrance of a loved one. Beautifully composed.
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
Thank You for the kind words Jibey! M so glad you liked it :)
From the photograph to the very last line... I do not believe that I had blinked nor took a single breath while reading this piece, Daisy. Sometimes... Sometimes we stumble upon writing that makes us feel blessed as the reader, instantly struck speechless by the sheer breathtaking talent of other's, when there are no words that can explain ones utter astonishment and praise... And this is one of those times. There are no lines to one by one pluck from this amazing poem as I had completely inhaled each and every word. And simply roar with applause as does the sky with thunderous pride... There is such a finality in with the word 'goodbye', so much that I find that it is a word that I rarely speak as there is always that hope for a 'see ya later'... So the final thought in this had struck me so deeply. Just... Wow!:)
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
You made my day with this deeply encouraging review! Only a writer as sensitive as you could come up.. read moreYou made my day with this deeply encouraging review! Only a writer as sensitive as you could come up with such a sensitive review (In your words) Sometimes we stumble upon readers who makes us feel blessed as a writer :) My heartiest thanks to you for this warm appreciation and m so glad you could resonate with my feelings. God Bless :)
A sad journey to a final goodbye.
"I hear your voice,
I feel your touch,
That bids to me-
That “Last Goodbye”
No goodbye is ever a good one. Thank you Daisy for sharing the excellent poetry.
Coyote
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
Thank You Coyote for your encouraging feedback as always :)