I deleted that odd first paragraph. That was NOT part of what I posted. Somehow, the site dumped in an unrelated first paragraph from something I sent to a spammer over a year ago.
Most odd, and certainly not meant for you.
• Oh I don`t know, what she`s up to
“She? The dog? The ghost? The politician? You know. The unknown “she” knows. But the reader, the one it’s written for, has not a clue. Does that make sense?
Think about it. Someone unknown, of unknown gender, age, and situation, is talking to an undefined “she,” about unstated events. That’s exactly as meaningful to a readeras a snippet of conversation heard from the people behind you in a restaurant.
Poetry isn’t us talking to the reader about what matters to us. That, no matter how poetically written is both a report and, irrelevant to those who don’t know us and our situation.
People come to poetry to be entertained by writing that will provide them with an emotional experience, not information on what matters to someone they don’t either know or care about. As E. L. Doctorow puts it: “Good writing is supposed to evoke sensation in the reader. Not the fact that it’s raining, but the feeling of being rained upon.”
By choice and placement of your words you have the power to make someone you will never meet laugh, cry, and feel the warmth of new love—if, you make use of the skills and knowledge that centuries of refinement of the poetic arts can provide.
The writing style we were given in school is fact-based and author-centric, as is your posted work. It’s great if your goal is writing a report, a letter, or an essay. But poetry requires a set of emotion-based skills, as does fiction.
They’re not hard to master, but they’re also not optional. So…
Mary Oliver is one hell of a poet. But she’s also produced a brilliant book, titled, A Poetry Handbook, one that should be required reading for anyone interested in writing poetry. You can download a copy here:
https://yes-pdf.com/book/1596
Try a chapter of two. I think you’ll be amazed at how obvious, and necessary the things she points out are.
So…I know this was pretty far from what you hoped to see, but still, since we’ll not address the problems we don’t see as being problems, I thought you might want to know.
Hang in there, and keep on writing.
Jay Greenstein
https://jaygreenstein.wordpress.com/category/the-craft-of-writing/the-grumpy-old-writing-coach/
Posted 2 Years Ago
0 of 1 people found this review constructive.
2 Years Ago
I don`t think people have to understand poetry. Poetry is for interpreting and projecting it onto yo.. read moreI don`t think people have to understand poetry. Poetry is for interpreting and projecting it onto your life and your situations. You don`t have to know who `she`is in my life, you have to think about who `she`is in your life. Everybody reads poetry differently- and poetry is not there for people to make sense.
Hello world, I am a 21 year old girl.
In the past years I struggled with addictions and self harm.
This is sort of a legacy or a contribution to the internet. My written down words make me immortal.. more..