This is heart wrenching for one who has been there. I can only speak for myself. I think the first 3 stanzas say it all. The lasts line of the third stanza is extremely powerful. I don't see how you can top that. I don't understand the last stanza. I am a bit thick headed. If I were to use all four stanzas I would switch 3 and 4 around. Very powerful.
This is my humble attempt to show civilian families what our loves live with. In many ways, he will .. read moreThis is my humble attempt to show civilian families what our loves live with. In many ways, he will always be there. Thank you for your beautiful review and thank you for your service.
I like it! I get that stanza now. I just noticed that "your love and his rifle" are in the first stanza and "his ghosts and his rifle" are in the final. Chilling with goose bumps.
This is heart wrenching for one who has been there. I can only speak for myself. I think the first 3 stanzas say it all. The lasts line of the third stanza is extremely powerful. I don't see how you can top that. I don't understand the last stanza. I am a bit thick headed. If I were to use all four stanzas I would switch 3 and 4 around. Very powerful.
This is my humble attempt to show civilian families what our loves live with. In many ways, he will .. read moreThis is my humble attempt to show civilian families what our loves live with. In many ways, he will always be there. Thank you for your beautiful review and thank you for your service.
I have thought about just deleting that last line, as well. I didn't want to just leave the piece ha.. read moreI have thought about just deleting that last line, as well. I didn't want to just leave the piece hanging... but that what war does. Thanks. I think I'll do that.
12 Years Ago
i just noticed the contrast between the firefights and sitting in the dark, this is really tight wor.. read morei just noticed the contrast between the firefights and sitting in the dark, this is really tight work
12 Years Ago
Thanks. I had a hard time with it, I think because I was trying to paint *him*. I've become adept at.. read moreThanks. I had a hard time with it, I think because I was trying to paint *him*. I've become adept at painting *me*. Ha! I think taking that last bit out made all the difference. Thank you :)
From my blinkers: The poem expresses the reality of today, but also opens the door to the history of human relationships. Relationships that have to grow love. Love in an a world where they are ordered to attack others.
Thanks for the quality. I don't see a problem with the end, but it depends what you wish to express.
I appreciate your take. I think I'm finding it hard to be real about this because I love him... and .. read moreI appreciate your take. I think I'm finding it hard to be real about this because I love him... and I want to do him justice. It's longer than my other pieces and that makes me uncomfortable. I detest lengthy crap. Just crap for the sake of spewing crap- you know? But thanks, friend.
Seriously, though, this was really good; I like the title a lot. I don't think it's too long, if anything, I think it needs more...just a little more. Like maybe bring to light the fact that the friends in his memories never actually made it home...like that. And the end makes me think maybe your love and his rifle are "still" for sinister reasons...I sincerely hope that is not the case.
:) Thank you. I agree with you on all points. No, not sinister reasons. More like... he goes away so.. read more:) Thank you. I agree with you on all points. No, not sinister reasons. More like... he goes away sometimes in the quiet. It does need something, I agree.
I imagine it takes a very strong person to live with a returning soldier; I commend you on your stre.. read moreI imagine it takes a very strong person to live with a returning soldier; I commend you on your strength.
12 Years Ago
I don't deserve that... I just love him. (and he's a Marine, not a soldier. Don't EVER let a Marine .. read moreI don't deserve that... I just love him. (and he's a Marine, not a soldier. Don't EVER let a Marine hear you call them a soldier lmao!! ) But thanks, love.
12 Years Ago
*laugh* sorry...and you know what? I just read that piece by DrD; you and all of the rest, yes you .. read more*laugh* sorry...and you know what? I just read that piece by DrD; you and all of the rest, yes you do deserve it. Good on ya, sister.
I am Alice through the looking glass...I mix my metaphors with barbiturates. I take my mania with a glass of milk and I rarely look before crossing the street. Walk a mile in my mary janes, friend.
.. more..