Do you think of me?
A Poem by beauitifulybroken
Friendship breakups suck
Sometimes i wonder
do you miss me
like i miss you?
Do you think of me
as i do with you
is there some
distant memory
that lingers within
is there a certain
scent
that sparks joy
within
when you think of me
is it with disdain
do you think fondly
of the time
we shared
two dreamers
navigating
scared in a world so
big
for two wandering
souls
do you hate me
when you think of
how we ended?
Do you grieve me
even though im still
living
because i do with
you
i find myself
missing
your hand in mine
the smell of your
shampoo
just to unwind
in the presence of
you
you used to be my
safe place
now your an
abandoned house
i haven’t visited
in years
I hope your doing
well
that life has
humbled you to some degree
that your tears
aren’t shed for nothing
that you haven’t
been used like you used me
that someone hasn’t
discarded you as you did with me
that you haven’t
been left like you left me
im dying to know
do you think of me?
© 2024 beauitifulybroken
Reviews
|
One of the problems with writing poetry with the approach you use, here, is that the words call up memories and reactions based on events in YOUR life. But they're events that the reader knows nothing about. And think about how that pre-knowledge effected the act of writing, and reading:
1. As you write, you're reacting to events that only you have context for. So the result is the presentation of effect without cause. How can that be meaningful to a reader who has been given no context to make the words meaningful to THEM? To the reader, someone of unknown gender and situation is sad because of the result of unspecified events. So what's in it for the reader?
You say, for example, "do you hate me when you think of how we ended?" When you read this, you know what happened. From the reader's viewpoint we not only don't know what happened, we don't know the why, the how, or, who might have been at fault. So yes, the reader has data, but no context to make it meaningful.
2. Because you've not looked into the skills of poetry that have been under development for centuries, you're not making use of stanzas, the poetic equivalent of paragraphing. So, we have a dense, foreboding, block of print.
Using the report-writing skills of nonfiction that we're given in school, you're talking TO the reader, as you would when writing a report, focused on explaining and reporting — informing, when the reader expects you to involve them, emotionally. You're talking of sadness to a reader who expects you to give them reason to be sad, not learning that you are. So, given the lack of context, what's on it for the reader?
No one tells us the goal of poetry and nonfiction is to involve the reader emotionally. So, we don't. But as E. L. Doctorow puts it: “Good writing is supposed to evoke sensation in the reader. Not the fact that it’s raining, but the feeling of being rained upon.” So, lacking that information, when we write, we think in terms of reporting and explaining. And because we have context and intent driving our emotion as we read our own work, it works exactly as it should.
For you, the narrator's voice is filled with the emotion that the rearder cannot know to place there. To better understand that, have your computer read the piece to you (Be warned, though, you may cry as it does 😆).
The thing is, it's not a matter of how well you write, or talent. It's that you're writing exactly as you were taught to, as do most hopeful writers, because we leave school believing that writing-is-writing, and, we have that taken care of. So, not aware that there is another approach, we don't seek one. And not seeing the problems, we'll never address them — which is why I thought you might want to know,
As Wilson Mizner wisely said, “If you steal from one author it’s plagiarism; if you steal from many it’s research.” So, research. Grab a copy of Mary Oliver's, A Poetry Handbook from the site linked to below. As a poet, her work is exceptional. And as a teacher, her book is a gem, start to finish. Try a few chapters and I think you'll agree.
https://www.docdroid.net/7iE8fIJ/a-poetry-handbook-pdfdrivecom-pdf
Jay Greenstein
Articles: https://jaygreenstein.wordpress.com/category/the-craft-of-writing/the-grumpy-old-writing-coach/
Videos: https://www.youtube.com/@jaygreenstein3334
--------
“It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so.”
~ Mark Twain
Posted 4 Months Ago
0 of 2 people found this review constructive.
|
4 Months Ago
While I must admit, at first your comment hurt my feelings a little bit, the constructive criticism .. read moreWhile I must admit, at first your comment hurt my feelings a little bit, the constructive criticism is definitely appreciated. I realize now that as the reader you are right there is a sense of it being a report rather then a poem and while it may be intimate to me the reader doesn't really see or feel the way I do. I appreciate your honesty and references, I will definitely look into those resources. Thank you!
|
|
|
|
Stats
63 Views
1 Review
Added on July 15, 2024
Last Updated on July 15, 2024
Author
beauitifulybrokenCanada
About
Inside there is a soul that is yearning to be heard,felt and seen. Letting my self express these thoughts and words help for that soul to feel a little less alone. more..
Writing
|