I didn't realize I still had this, or I would've uploaded it sooner. =P This is for my boyfriend, about the first moment I realized I loved him.
Thank you for any critiques!
My Review
Would you like to review this Poem? Login | Register
nothing boring here...that first inkling, the epiphany of how we really love someone, despite the messiness...because really messiness is reality...one that we suddenly perceive we do not want to lose--
i like the end...taking his cue to breathe....and maybe close our own eyes and let them hide behind our lids...
It's funny how some of us remember moments like these. I find it sensitive and highly visual. You taught me a new word! Yes, I had to go look up "detritus". Some might warn against using a fancy word like that, but I'm ok with it. Very nice work, Emma.
This a very vivid expression of unconditional love. Very emotional and descriptive. I also love how you did not stick with the usual vertical poem structure. Thank you for sharing and please return the favor by reviewing one of my pieces.
Here's my problem with critique Emma. Writing, for example, a sonnet and asking for critique on the form, is fine, but a great deal of poetry is a personal thing, often written from actual experience and from the heart. Thus, in my view, critique,unless one is talking form, grammar or sentence construction, which sadly is rather lacking these days, seems rather crass. Truly, I simply prefer to read, absorb, then interpret, (always difficult as interpretation is so subjective,) what the writer is trying to convey.
Anyway, that's my excuse. Beccy :)
Posted 10 Years Ago
10 Years Ago
Well, of course, but if you're going to critique you don't analyze message (whatever the writer want.. read moreWell, of course, but if you're going to critique you don't analyze message (whatever the writer wants to convey is their own business and prerogative) but instead analyze the effectiveness of the delivery of the message. Of course dictating subject matter would be crass (though suggestions on ways to pull and prod at the subject matter can often be helpful), but if a poet is trying to evoke an emotion or paint a scene you, as a reader, are a primary source which can offer feedback as to how effective the communication of said emotion or scene is. Critique is absolutely vital for the improvement of individual works and a writer as a whole - it gives you the opportunity to not only suggest better ways of relaying the core message of the poem, but also highlights what the author succeeded at and why. Critiquing form is a part of that, anyways. Form lends to meaning - so do grammar and sentence construction. Too many people on this site shy away from critique. If you want to be successful in any artistic medium, though, you need to know not only how to take critique but how to give it. I would encourage you to not write it off for fear of offending another individual - if you don't understand what they're trying to say that's important to hear. How do they improve their work otherwise?
PS, I never critique poetry, almost always it's a personal thing. I simply read and absorb and mostly enjoy.
Posted 10 Years Ago
10 Years Ago
That's too bad. Every work could use critiques because they not only help the author but also the wr.. read moreThat's too bad. Every work could use critiques because they not only help the author but also the writer of the critique. Thank you for your comment!
Such a nice way to express every minute movement of your love! Only the heart with love and eyes with full of faith can do this....Great arc of the poetic art!
This is amazing. Thank you for this bit of beauty now in my life. As others, I love the last line. To me, it is the reminder of reality and love for another ask together in one- it is the bringing of that love into life. I aspire to write beautifully, and this is an amazing example of how that looks.
PLEASE don't waste my time if you're going to get defensive. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE I am begging you. I promise you that I will say things that will help you (I mean, most of my reviews are around 25-30.. more..