I wrote this poem with only the first and last sets of stanzas and it felt unfinished to me, like it needed some explanatory verses, so I wrote the middle set of stanzas. Then after reading it, I found it felt overwritten or even forced. I was up and down on what I should do so I am going to ask you, whoever stops by to read it...what do you think? First and last set of stanzas or the entire poem?
My Review
Would you like to review this Poem? Login | Register
Definitely the entire poem. That's my opinion for what it's worth.
It's beautiful, sad, and has a happy ending but the middle verse creates such a strong emotional connection. I can't imagine not including it. Anyhow, it's a beautiful poem no matter which way.
Posted 7 Months Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Months Ago
Thanks Ana. Your poetic opinion means more to me than most. Thank you for taking the time to read an.. read moreThanks Ana. Your poetic opinion means more to me than most. Thank you for taking the time to read and let me know what you think. I appreciate your visits.
Definitely the entire poem. That's my opinion for what it's worth.
It's beautiful, sad, and has a happy ending but the middle verse creates such a strong emotional connection. I can't imagine not including it. Anyhow, it's a beautiful poem no matter which way.
Posted 7 Months Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Months Ago
Thanks Ana. Your poetic opinion means more to me than most. Thank you for taking the time to read an.. read moreThanks Ana. Your poetic opinion means more to me than most. Thank you for taking the time to read and let me know what you think. I appreciate your visits.
Will it can go either way depending on the feeling that you want to leave the reader. The two stanzas alone leave it more up to the reader to interpret their way but to leave out the middle stanzas looses some beautiful lines
"He was her rock,
a feeling protected,
stupid, this argument, got out of hand
Harsh words were said,
the anger repeated,
thinking it best it was time he was gone"
Just my opinion, for what that is worth, about as much as it cost.
Posted 1 Year Ago
1 Year Ago
Thanks Soren, I appreciate it. I was just very undecided on this, which is unlike me. But I think th.. read moreThanks Soren, I appreciate it. I was just very undecided on this, which is unlike me. But I think the posted version is the best, at least for this poem. Thanks again my friend.
I think the entire poem because the middle gives a hint as to why he needs her forgiveness...the harsh words...otherwise we are so in the dark that it is hard to advance an idea for the reader to find explanation even for his or her own interpretation.
j.
Posted 1 Year Ago
1 Year Ago
Thanks so much Jacob, that makes sense and I appreciate your time.
I think they both work Will, but would leave it as is. In my humble opinion.
Beautiful write either way.
Posted 1 Year Ago
1 Year Ago
Thanks my friend. I appreciate you taking the time to read and comment. I think I like this version .. read moreThanks my friend. I appreciate you taking the time to read and comment. I think I like this version the best too.
Hi, I am willweb. Maybe you remember me and maybe you don't. I have been writing here on and off for years. I pop in and write and read and comment and make friends and learn new things.
I enjoy maki.. more..