They Weren't all that Different, ReallyA Poem by Tomás Ó CárthaighInspired by the plotline of the book and film "Boy in the Striped Pyjamas"
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The Boy in the Striped PyjamasWatch an exclusive clip from the movie
|
The rhythm is all crazy here... just kotting as Im thinking... will edit to make better...
|
Featured Review
This is something we - here in Deutschland - never will forget.. I'd say this is a half rhyme structure, which you used as a function to distinguish between the past and now....your narrative poem by using the word - Jews - is heightening the expression without prejudicial intent I interpreted this as expression of value. Once in English poetry the use of rhyme in the end words was in order to compensate for the sometimes unsatisfactory quality, I have read this somewhere, but your quality here is great, it is the way how everything is put together. in my opinion, no need to change. great write.
Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
Reviews
I like this work very much. The rhythm seems completely appropriate, considering the content. The world of which you speak was akilter, without rhyme or reason. It's most touching in its starkness.
Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
It's amazing how people feel like segments of their lives can be separated from other parts of their lives. Economic choices and moral choices end up affecting other people; tragically, children can be affected by the actions of parents (or others).
When I read this, I felt . . . so sorry for the parents, . . . a taste of the fear of this boy, and . . . anger that people could be so filled with hatred that they'd be willing to exterminate others. I think that if that was your purpose in writing this poem, then this poem is definately a success. Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
This is something we - here in Deutschland - never will forget.. I'd say this is a half rhyme structure, which you used as a function to distinguish between the past and now....your narrative poem by using the word - Jews - is heightening the expression without prejudicial intent I interpreted this as expression of value. Once in English poetry the use of rhyme in the end words was in order to compensate for the sometimes unsatisfactory quality, I have read this somewhere, but your quality here is great, it is the way how everything is put together. in my opinion, no need to change. great write.
Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
A stunning portrayal of the innocence and truth of youth! I really don't much concern myself with flow and rhythm and that sort ~ though I am sure a true poet does. What the words induce me to feel is my guage for fine writing. And this is it.
Brutal and tragic realism. Well done! j Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
A few typos, but nothing major. The rythym is not bad, just differant. Could be a good think because it forces the reader to slow down. The only major problem I see is the line "Only for the camp section to be on a march to be sent" that was difficult to work through. I don't know how exactly you meant it to sound, but it is confusing as written. On the positive side, this is a very interesting poem, I do like the rythym and the ending is, as melanie said, amazing.
Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
I think it's perfect as is. I'm not sure a real regular rhythm would tell the same story. And what a story!
Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
I couldn't avoid stumbling over the typos but as you said, you'll get to it. I think it was an amazing ending. It did indeed affect alot more people than just one persecuted people. Thank you for sharing this and I'll be checking out this movie and book you refer to .
Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
This was sad. :( I'm well aware that the Holocaust didn't just take the lives of Jews alone. This poem does an excellent job of acknowledging that.
Very well-done. BTW, the rhyme isn't all bad. ;) Ironically Yours, Blade and Blood Posted 16 Years Ago1 of 1 people found this review constructive. |
Stats
8 Reviews
Added on September 12, 2008
Author
Tomás Ó Cárthaigh
Renmore, Galway, Ireland, An Roinne Mór, Gallaimh, Eire, Ireland
About
Ten years on this site... a quick decade, and an age in another way... Flanagan and the Lampost The Novena, some Drama and Midge Ure in Galway Fiddling at Longford Donkey Innovat.. more..Writing
I Surrounded Them MyselfA Poem by Tomás Ó C&a.. |
Moneenageisha Harbour, Lo..A Poem by Tomás Ó C&a.. |
Christmas Reflection 2019A Poem by Tomás Ó C&a.. |
Related Writing
People who liked this story also liked..
THE HANGER OF SILKSA Poem by R J Askew |
Rapturous PassionA Poem by Phill Oz O'fee |
Best FriendA Poem by Phill Oz O'fee |
The Ramblings of a Grain ..A Story by Phill Oz O'fee |