This is a spectacular piece of writing, with a profound message and deep sadness. I salute you--very nicely done.
Now have always respected David Paget's remarks when I have read them in reviews, and indeed here as well, they are all quite true. However, I think this is mostly a matter of taste and opinion. The mixing of thy/thou with chap doesn't disturb me at all. To me, these are all words well understood by almost everyone, i.e., these are all but elements of language, not incorrect, simply different. Yes, one is archaic and one more modern. David's point is well taken, but again, I think it a matter of taste. The "weak" lost//thought rhyme is also not a problems for me.
Now to the message of the poem, which seems so heartfelt. Very well expressed. The emotion fountains from the words. A very powerful message with perfect form makes for a tremendous poem. Very top marks. A rare 98% from me. I've never rated a poem higher.
This is a spectacular piece of writing, with a profound message and deep sadness. I salute you--very nicely done.
Now have always respected David Paget's remarks when I have read them in reviews, and indeed here as well, they are all quite true. However, I think this is mostly a matter of taste and opinion. The mixing of thy/thou with chap doesn't disturb me at all. To me, these are all words well understood by almost everyone, i.e., these are all but elements of language, not incorrect, simply different. Yes, one is archaic and one more modern. David's point is well taken, but again, I think it a matter of taste. The "weak" lost//thought rhyme is also not a problems for me.
Now to the message of the poem, which seems so heartfelt. Very well expressed. The emotion fountains from the words. A very powerful message with perfect form makes for a tremendous poem. Very top marks. A rare 98% from me. I've never rated a poem higher.
You've pretty well come to grips with this form, Todd. Quite impresssive! There are only a couple of places I would take you to task here, for inappropriate rhyming words - 'lost/thought' for example. I would also question the use of 'thy/thou' which are archaic, as used in the same verse as 'chap', which is horribly modern. Otherwise, great stuff!
Whew, a strong message to all who are far from our Savior...sor many it will be too late to receive this message of yours..I pray many read this..lol and God bless..Kathie
C.T. Bailey has authored a number of professional articles which have been published in various industry trade publications. He is also an award-winning and published writer of poetry, prose, and fic.. more..