See, I disagree with Trigorin, I don't think that the topic is generic at all. I mean, everything has already been written in some way or another, unless you're writing about some JUST discovered algea on Mars or something, so to say that writing about love and loss has been "done" is correct, but to call it "generic"...no. Anyway, with that out of the way, I like this one. It reminds me a little of the piece I wrote about burning letters. There is an innate longing here that is really quite new and fresh. The wording is beautiful and the emotion is sensory. Well done.
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
Well I did write about smartdust, recently :P That hasn't been tried by Trigorin I don't think....
11 Years Ago
Yes it's about poets who fell in love over a long distance and wrong many poems to each other, some .. read moreYes it's about poets who fell in love over a long distance and wrong many poems to each other, some secret and some shared.
11 Years Ago
*wrote
11 Years Ago
Read some of Trigorin's poetry...I'm not saying it's not good, but the topics are in no way "absolut.. read moreRead some of Trigorin's poetry...I'm not saying it's not good, but the topics are in no way "absolutely new"...lol
As for your piece...I sort of figured that was what it was about.
11 Years Ago
Been there done that, I find his honest reviews amusing though, though I imagine his avatar to be a .. read moreBeen there done that, I find his honest reviews amusing though, though I imagine his avatar to be a very frightening RAT!
11 Years Ago
a poser and a turdburglar
11 Years Ago
I can't quite figure out what it is, actually...and it's not that I haven't tried...
It reminds me of that commercial they had on for a while for the Quizno's Subs...with the smashed ra.. read moreIt reminds me of that commercial they had on for a while for the Quizno's Subs...with the smashed rat thing that would sing and dance...I don't know if scary is the word I would use; perhaps morbidly entertaining.
i think this is great. just because some over inflated ego visits your write and says it's generic doesn't mean it is. i am always happy to see writers expressing themselves honestly and i applaud your efforts to do so. this is writerscafe, an avenue for us to explore our talents...not to be slammed by puffed up self important buffoons who begin almost every review they do with "not bad"....when it becomes a publisher's clearing house i'm sure someone who actually has some weight around here will let us know. very good write!
See, I disagree with Trigorin, I don't think that the topic is generic at all. I mean, everything has already been written in some way or another, unless you're writing about some JUST discovered algea on Mars or something, so to say that writing about love and loss has been "done" is correct, but to call it "generic"...no. Anyway, with that out of the way, I like this one. It reminds me a little of the piece I wrote about burning letters. There is an innate longing here that is really quite new and fresh. The wording is beautiful and the emotion is sensory. Well done.
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
Well I did write about smartdust, recently :P That hasn't been tried by Trigorin I don't think....
11 Years Ago
Yes it's about poets who fell in love over a long distance and wrong many poems to each other, some .. read moreYes it's about poets who fell in love over a long distance and wrong many poems to each other, some secret and some shared.
11 Years Ago
*wrote
11 Years Ago
Read some of Trigorin's poetry...I'm not saying it's not good, but the topics are in no way "absolut.. read moreRead some of Trigorin's poetry...I'm not saying it's not good, but the topics are in no way "absolutely new"...lol
As for your piece...I sort of figured that was what it was about.
11 Years Ago
Been there done that, I find his honest reviews amusing though, though I imagine his avatar to be a .. read moreBeen there done that, I find his honest reviews amusing though, though I imagine his avatar to be a very frightening RAT!
11 Years Ago
a poser and a turdburglar
11 Years Ago
I can't quite figure out what it is, actually...and it's not that I haven't tried...
It reminds me of that commercial they had on for a while for the Quizno's Subs...with the smashed ra.. read moreIt reminds me of that commercial they had on for a while for the Quizno's Subs...with the smashed rat thing that would sing and dance...I don't know if scary is the word I would use; perhaps morbidly entertaining.
Not bad. You put a lot of emotion into this piece and while its topic is fairly generic and done, you manage to make it interesting and hold the reader's attention. Well done.
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
wow knowing how you review, this is praise, I think!