I very seldom reply to reviews, but I promise I read EVERY single one. I look forward to my next review, because it helps me learn. Even if it's just one word, I promise, I will be ecstatic to have the chance to hear what you have to say. Whenever you write something about my poems, or the themes of my poems, or criticize me it is not in vain. I will listen, learn and be thankful.
My Review
Would you like to review this Poem? Login | Register
I'm going to review this stanza-by-stanza (though I might skip some if I feel like there's nothing substantial to comment about):
1: I love how you used the word "little" over and over again, but then hit us with "And everything was grand". Really good contrast.
2-4: I'm writing this as I read it, so pardon my inability to see into the future. I have a feeling based on the description that it really isn't. Perhaps you're going to talk about the concept of freedom in a society that tells you to go to school, go to college, get a job, pay your bills, retire, and die, and nothing more. Regardless, let me continue reading.
5-6: I was right about things not going right. I also love how you said that the doctor couldn't give a f**k. It really isolates him from the rest of the town.
7: This is a nice hyperbole as to what really happens. It puts it into perspective who aren't struggling through mental illness.
10: First, I skipped 8 and 9 because it's fairly straight-forward. This man is indeed a man. This would mean that his depression was provoked by something. Why couldn't he be the same? Typically, if depression emerges that late, it's not genetics. Could he not have rebuilt his life? Or, perhaps it's because he can't because of the illness. To that, I'll counter my other monologue half by saying that he could go to a therapist. To which I counter with the fact that if everything is nice, there's no need for therapists.
11: You're doing a fantastic job with the "nice and little". You're putting it in different contexts, and that really pronounces it.
13: I thought it already turned gray, which is dark? Though, I'm nit-picking and semantics-ing.
14: I love this stanza in particular. It really highlights the struggles that people go through with mental illness. I don't know what you're going to say next (again, I'm writing as I read), but maybe you'll say something that tells the audience that thought is the most damaging weapon to someone with a mental illness. I have to ask, and you don't have to answer if this is too personal, do you personally struggle with a mental illness?
15: "Nothing was nice anymore". Nice line!
16: Great metaphors!
17-20: I have to wonder if you'll address the reason as to why this happens, or if you're to leave the reader wondering as to the reasoning behind it.
21-23: Very abrupt switch. It went from pure pessimism to almost something like Taoism. Revelations don't happen that fast (though, this might be hyperbole to help the reader understand it better).
24: Nope, I was right when I said somewhere up there ^ about the fact that the man can make his existence better.
25: Woah! Hold the phone. Now this changes everything! You literally meant "little". You meant he was a child (comparatively). That was awesome! You used a common phrase in a literal sense, knowing that it would be taken as the metaphorical sense, then you revealed how old this person actually was. Now I fully understand why he would believe that his life could be rebuilt. This is a new style of reviewing for me, so I probably sound ignorant up there ^, because I was.
26: Very clean closing. In my opinion, a little too clean. I have to wonder what caused the depression. If it was genetics, then it wouldn't be that clean. If it was just being a teenager, it could be that clean. A lot is left to wondering. But it's not in a bad way. You revealed enough, and gave us a guide. So, it's a good sort of omission.
Overall: Fantastic story! I loved it. I'm giving this the highest rating I've ever given a story before: 98/100. The only reason it's not 100 is because of the abrupt switch from miserably depressed to cautiously optimistic recovery. However, fantastic story! I'm so glad you asked me to read this.
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
I'm happy you like this story, and I really appreciate the review. I've been struggling with mental .. read moreI'm happy you like this story, and I really appreciate the review. I've been struggling with mental illness for a long time, so I know what it feels like. I've spent almost three years of my life hospitalized where I learned to cope with depression. I feel like depression is an issue that is not covered as much as it should be, especially with children and teenagers. So I created "little man" to show a teenager growing up with depression. This poem is about 25% my experiences, but the rest is different. This poem isn't really about me, it's about the struggles people go through, and how things can change at the flip of a coin. When this happens, you have put a lot of effort into rebuilding your life. It could take years, like with the little man.
This was a truthful poem on life. It shows the grim reality of life and the way you have continuously used the word nice was really very effective. This poem sticks to the fact that life has ups and downs. This poem also had a good story and I liked how that little man didn't give up even when his faith quivered.
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
Thank you for the review, I really appreciate it! Depression is a big part of the lives of a lot of .. read moreThank you for the review, I really appreciate it! Depression is a big part of the lives of a lot of people. I just wish everyone could be like the little man and not give into it.
I'm going to review this stanza-by-stanza (though I might skip some if I feel like there's nothing substantial to comment about):
1: I love how you used the word "little" over and over again, but then hit us with "And everything was grand". Really good contrast.
2-4: I'm writing this as I read it, so pardon my inability to see into the future. I have a feeling based on the description that it really isn't. Perhaps you're going to talk about the concept of freedom in a society that tells you to go to school, go to college, get a job, pay your bills, retire, and die, and nothing more. Regardless, let me continue reading.
5-6: I was right about things not going right. I also love how you said that the doctor couldn't give a f**k. It really isolates him from the rest of the town.
7: This is a nice hyperbole as to what really happens. It puts it into perspective who aren't struggling through mental illness.
10: First, I skipped 8 and 9 because it's fairly straight-forward. This man is indeed a man. This would mean that his depression was provoked by something. Why couldn't he be the same? Typically, if depression emerges that late, it's not genetics. Could he not have rebuilt his life? Or, perhaps it's because he can't because of the illness. To that, I'll counter my other monologue half by saying that he could go to a therapist. To which I counter with the fact that if everything is nice, there's no need for therapists.
11: You're doing a fantastic job with the "nice and little". You're putting it in different contexts, and that really pronounces it.
13: I thought it already turned gray, which is dark? Though, I'm nit-picking and semantics-ing.
14: I love this stanza in particular. It really highlights the struggles that people go through with mental illness. I don't know what you're going to say next (again, I'm writing as I read), but maybe you'll say something that tells the audience that thought is the most damaging weapon to someone with a mental illness. I have to ask, and you don't have to answer if this is too personal, do you personally struggle with a mental illness?
15: "Nothing was nice anymore". Nice line!
16: Great metaphors!
17-20: I have to wonder if you'll address the reason as to why this happens, or if you're to leave the reader wondering as to the reasoning behind it.
21-23: Very abrupt switch. It went from pure pessimism to almost something like Taoism. Revelations don't happen that fast (though, this might be hyperbole to help the reader understand it better).
24: Nope, I was right when I said somewhere up there ^ about the fact that the man can make his existence better.
25: Woah! Hold the phone. Now this changes everything! You literally meant "little". You meant he was a child (comparatively). That was awesome! You used a common phrase in a literal sense, knowing that it would be taken as the metaphorical sense, then you revealed how old this person actually was. Now I fully understand why he would believe that his life could be rebuilt. This is a new style of reviewing for me, so I probably sound ignorant up there ^, because I was.
26: Very clean closing. In my opinion, a little too clean. I have to wonder what caused the depression. If it was genetics, then it wouldn't be that clean. If it was just being a teenager, it could be that clean. A lot is left to wondering. But it's not in a bad way. You revealed enough, and gave us a guide. So, it's a good sort of omission.
Overall: Fantastic story! I loved it. I'm giving this the highest rating I've ever given a story before: 98/100. The only reason it's not 100 is because of the abrupt switch from miserably depressed to cautiously optimistic recovery. However, fantastic story! I'm so glad you asked me to read this.
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
I'm happy you like this story, and I really appreciate the review. I've been struggling with mental .. read moreI'm happy you like this story, and I really appreciate the review. I've been struggling with mental illness for a long time, so I know what it feels like. I've spent almost three years of my life hospitalized where I learned to cope with depression. I feel like depression is an issue that is not covered as much as it should be, especially with children and teenagers. So I created "little man" to show a teenager growing up with depression. This poem is about 25% my experiences, but the rest is different. This poem isn't really about me, it's about the struggles people go through, and how things can change at the flip of a coin. When this happens, you have put a lot of effort into rebuilding your life. It could take years, like with the little man.
Most of my poems can be differing lengths depending on the time you want to spend reading them. You can avoid reading anything brackets, or read it all. If you want an in-between, you can read only th.. more..