Ah, Shane. Refreshing to see a short poetry request. These are a little easier to handle than the prose I usually get asked to look over. Anyway, you have summoned me, and thus I will do as you ask.
My first suggestion will likely be an unusual one. I loathe the title. Seriously, can't stand it. Though writers and word lovers in general may know Pharology, and it does make sense, it just feels too wordy for such a quick hitting and strong work. Yes, I have positive marks for you, but I prefer to make the more important commentary first. I recommend referencing timelessness or the sand. How about "Hourglass"? This poem slowly reveals a distant lighthouse to your reader, and the title should give a little sense of mystery. I don't like titles that give away the ending, if you catch my drift.
You've earned a soft spot in my heart for successful alliteration. I don't think I need to remind you how powerful this can be in the right hands, and you have not only used it correctly, but thoroughly weaponized it. Bravo. It also implies a deeper meaning that only some may catch; are YOU the lighthouse? Or, is no one?
Beyond that, I have little else to say, as my only grievance with this work revolves around the title. Still, if you ever need an editor for larger works, I'm always accepting new contracts. I'll be in touch. Oh, and give some of my stuff a read sometime. Song of Sinai is back in the workshop, but the more folks that know my name, the better.
Ah, Shane. Refreshing to see a short poetry request. These are a little easier to handle than the prose I usually get asked to look over. Anyway, you have summoned me, and thus I will do as you ask.
My first suggestion will likely be an unusual one. I loathe the title. Seriously, can't stand it. Though writers and word lovers in general may know Pharology, and it does make sense, it just feels too wordy for such a quick hitting and strong work. Yes, I have positive marks for you, but I prefer to make the more important commentary first. I recommend referencing timelessness or the sand. How about "Hourglass"? This poem slowly reveals a distant lighthouse to your reader, and the title should give a little sense of mystery. I don't like titles that give away the ending, if you catch my drift.
You've earned a soft spot in my heart for successful alliteration. I don't think I need to remind you how powerful this can be in the right hands, and you have not only used it correctly, but thoroughly weaponized it. Bravo. It also implies a deeper meaning that only some may catch; are YOU the lighthouse? Or, is no one?
Beyond that, I have little else to say, as my only grievance with this work revolves around the title. Still, if you ever need an editor for larger works, I'm always accepting new contracts. I'll be in touch. Oh, and give some of my stuff a read sometime. Song of Sinai is back in the workshop, but the more folks that know my name, the better.
Crafted beautifully ! The comparisons, the depth of it all and the imagery is spot on grand! The words flow with one another causing for the poem to have a statement of its own ! Brilliant :)
Posted 10 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
John the Baptist 2.0
Fake online mental health pro
A-mazing. It comes off as both gentle and dramatic through the depiction of a calm coastline contrasted to a lighthouse rising from sand. Incredible imagery.
Love the alliteration, 'Shattered shards,' 'Gathering and gaining.' And that line, 'Infinite aspects in finite views,' is what being an artist is all about. A serious poem but wonderfully musical to say out loud. Nice one Irish ;)