Just one chapter from my pending book. Just looking for your critique on the story
The
sun set below the tree line creating a luminous glow over the swamp lands. It
was the first Wednesday of September and alligator hunting season had just
begun. The sound of airboats vibrated the murky, algae filled waters of the
Atchafalaya river. With each vibration the water would ripple, and the enormous
bald cypress trees swayed their branches into the sediment riddled waters. As
the boat’s propellers came to a stop the swamp became quiet and it was only
broken with the occasional gator call. In the middle of the swamp a tourist
boat sat, and two tour guides faced their audience welcoming them to the swamplands.
Both tour guides wore camouflage from head to toe, one with a gray wiry bear
stood up, giving his speech in a thick creole accent, “ Welcume to Cajun Pride
Tours. Tuday we will be showen ya the swamp lands of Louisana. This here is
Nolan and he’ll be fipinn us around to fin us sume gator”. The beared man sat
down letting, Nolan speed the boat around towards a thick portion of the
cypress trees. The airboat made its way through the thick branches coasting
away letting the branches swing behind them. Behind the curtain of branches an
area surrounded by large tree trunks shot up out of the water. The bark of the
trunks peeled showing the different shades of brown. Inside the canopy the
weather had cooled drastically, and the humidity seemed to dissipate from the
air. High in the trees hanging down were hundreds of green and blue colored
bottles.The hint of sunlight that beamed through the canopy penetrated the
colored glasses shining beautiful colored light all around the enclosed space. The tourist were in
awe of the bottles and began clicking away at their cameras. There clicking
away was interrupted by the tour guide with the white wiry beard, “Oh, these
are called bottle trees. How they work is you trap your enemies in the bottle
and then hang them from the trees so the sun can destroy them. Although people
beleve they are fun and games…”. His sentence was interrupted by the drop of
one of the bottles, startling the tourists. A voice from the trees came down and recited,
“Some amongst we
The evil will take over
They done forgot what the ancestors taught we
We hang the bottles for a trap the evil spirits
that threaten us
To keep we people strong
This here who we be
This sacred tree can protect we
If we protect one another
It be the ancestor way
Be we way
It gwana be the children way”
The voice
stopped and another one of the bottles hit the water. The two tour guides
looked at each other with wide eyes, under their breath they both began to
recite the Lord’s prayer in creole French. Nolan tried to turn the engine on
the boat, but it came to a stall. He said voice still shaking “It ain’t workin,
the boat”.He continued to try to turn the engine on with every time resulting
in failure. As he continued, the voice became louder and the chant became
faster, and multiple bottles began to drop down into the murky water splashing
the tourist and the tour guides in the boat with muddy water. PLOP PLOP PLOP!!!
With the splashing of the water then boat moved forward towards the portion of
land directly in front. The slow movement of the boat swayed with the waters
own organic movement and the sound of the bottles plopping into the water
slowed. The tourist and their guides, all waited in terror for the boat to hit
the land, but this never happened. The boat was trying to move forward but was
tugged back by something underneath. Every time the boat tried to move it would
jerk back to its original position, simulating a rubber band effect. Both the
tour guides got out of the boat looking for the trunk or branch that had been
preventing them from moving onto the land. They moved the boat backwards trying
to release the boat. They kept pushing both still reciting The Lord’s Prayer in
their native tongue. With three big pushes the boat moved backwards and unveiled
the cause of its sudden stop. A light brown colored object was floating. The
men moved closer toward the object now with more curiosity on their faces than
fear. There bodies immune to the cold swamp water and dodging falling bottles
as they moved closer to the object. The man with the wiry beard was holding a
bang gun, normally used for hunting gators. As they approached the object the
bearded man poked it with his bang gun. The object rolled over revealing a
white colored bloated body. The men let out an “AAARH” sound and began to swim
towards the boat. The tourist was confused too far away to see the body of the
old wrinkly pale bloated lady in the water. Then men swam back and lifted
themselves onto the boat. The boat turned on suddenly and Nolan reached for the
gears, and they drove off into the dark sky, towards the dock interrupting the
silence of the swamp.
The descriptive narrative in the first half of this chapter, as you call it, is stunning. There are some technical errors in the grammar (eg. comma splices and missing hyphens), and some other spelling errors ("bearded" is the word you're looking for; and also you use "tourist" a lot when it should be plural), but the way the story moved was stupendous. By the time the dialogue starts, however, it just falls flat, and the narrative kind of can't weave in the same way. If this chapter were to all be that beautifully constructed descriptive narrative, it would be much better, and the clunky tourist dialogue, which doesn't add anything (and we're led to question how we're supposed to understand that the guides are reciting the Lord's Prayer "in their own language" if it's a different language). The finding of the body was great and added something, but the progression from there just didn't have the same effect as the first half and didn't do that story beat any justice (for also, Nolan said he couldn't get the boat to start, so how suddenly could he start the boat after they find the body?). Things weren't falling in their places like the first half pre-dialogue. Set things up a little better, because what made the first half so good was that it felt immersive, and afterwards it just felt like being fed seemingly useless information. But you have a great start. I do mean what I say that your choice in narrative is fantastic. You just have a few kinks to sort out.
Posted 4 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
4 Years Ago
Thank You so much for your critique of the story. I really appreciate the honest feedback. Thank you.. read moreThank You so much for your critique of the story. I really appreciate the honest feedback. Thank you for reading
The descriptive narrative in the first half of this chapter, as you call it, is stunning. There are some technical errors in the grammar (eg. comma splices and missing hyphens), and some other spelling errors ("bearded" is the word you're looking for; and also you use "tourist" a lot when it should be plural), but the way the story moved was stupendous. By the time the dialogue starts, however, it just falls flat, and the narrative kind of can't weave in the same way. If this chapter were to all be that beautifully constructed descriptive narrative, it would be much better, and the clunky tourist dialogue, which doesn't add anything (and we're led to question how we're supposed to understand that the guides are reciting the Lord's Prayer "in their own language" if it's a different language). The finding of the body was great and added something, but the progression from there just didn't have the same effect as the first half and didn't do that story beat any justice (for also, Nolan said he couldn't get the boat to start, so how suddenly could he start the boat after they find the body?). Things weren't falling in their places like the first half pre-dialogue. Set things up a little better, because what made the first half so good was that it felt immersive, and afterwards it just felt like being fed seemingly useless information. But you have a great start. I do mean what I say that your choice in narrative is fantastic. You just have a few kinks to sort out.
Posted 4 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
4 Years Ago
Thank You so much for your critique of the story. I really appreciate the honest feedback. Thank you.. read moreThank You so much for your critique of the story. I really appreciate the honest feedback. Thank you for reading