Ultimately, I felt like this poem could have been stretched out and more connected. For example here, "What hope have you lost,/What joy can be found?/ You wish it was you," What does it mean to lose hope or joy. Does dying mean these feelings die as well? What does having hell to pay mean?
I felt you could have connected these lines, "who froze,/instead of they;/ At least they’re free," I felt you could have extended the metaphor of freezing to being free."
I really liked the first line and the last couple of lines. I liked that you laid out the poem to talk about the death of other things besides just the ending of a life. This line, "You discover new hope in spite of the strife" gives a redemptive quality to it. I just wish it was extended more.
Thanks for posting!
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
I understand where you are coming from, but I have to disagree. Sure, this poem could be extended, j.. read moreI understand where you are coming from, but I have to disagree. Sure, this poem could be extended, just like any poem really, and more ideas could be added. But I feel as if I said everything I wanted to say already. Those two lines you mention are already connected, in fact, the whole poem is connected. If I explain to much, then the reader would not have to do any work. Thank you though for the criticism!
Ultimately, I felt like this poem could have been stretched out and more connected. For example here, "What hope have you lost,/What joy can be found?/ You wish it was you," What does it mean to lose hope or joy. Does dying mean these feelings die as well? What does having hell to pay mean?
I felt you could have connected these lines, "who froze,/instead of they;/ At least they’re free," I felt you could have extended the metaphor of freezing to being free."
I really liked the first line and the last couple of lines. I liked that you laid out the poem to talk about the death of other things besides just the ending of a life. This line, "You discover new hope in spite of the strife" gives a redemptive quality to it. I just wish it was extended more.
Thanks for posting!
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
I understand where you are coming from, but I have to disagree. Sure, this poem could be extended, j.. read moreI understand where you are coming from, but I have to disagree. Sure, this poem could be extended, just like any poem really, and more ideas could be added. But I feel as if I said everything I wanted to say already. Those two lines you mention are already connected, in fact, the whole poem is connected. If I explain to much, then the reader would not have to do any work. Thank you though for the criticism!
I am a Junior Writing/Psychology student attending Houghton College in western NY. I enjoy writing both poetry and fiction, which usually center around some sort of psychological or philosophical idea.. more..