Hi Niruparma. Couple of comments. As regards the content of the poem, I like the topic of the shadow. You would probably know that shadows have been written about in poems, songs etc since for ever, so it's hard to find a new angle, but you have some nice concepts here - the brightness, the idea that the shadow is more loveable.
Second comment is the meter, which I would say is not limerick. Think of 3/4 time musical bars. I have just counted in my head, and there should be 13 such bars, arranged 3 3 2 2 3. To show what I mean, here's an instant example which means nothing, but sticks rigidly to the meter and rhythm
There was a - young fellow - called Peter
Who had a - godmother - named Rita
When out on - excursions
They tried dif - ferent versions
Of sitting - upon a - two-seater
Just to be really pedantic about this, you can also drop the final syllable on every line, so long as it's on all lines. So in terms of syllables, it could be 8 (3, 3, 2) 8 (3, 3, 2) 5 (3, 2) 5 (3, 2) 8 (3, 3, 2). So in your poem, lines 1, 2 and 5 have the 'right' number of syllables, but not quite the right meter.
I know this sounds critical and that you were just experimenting. So please regard these comments as genuine attempts to be helpful.
Regards
Nigel
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
Thanks a lot for your time and effort.
I've just started learning the basics of poetry (mostl.. read moreThanks a lot for your time and effort.
I've just started learning the basics of poetry (mostly by myself through blogs and other similar resources). Your comment has been extremely helpful to me.
Hi Niruparma. Couple of comments. As regards the content of the poem, I like the topic of the shadow. You would probably know that shadows have been written about in poems, songs etc since for ever, so it's hard to find a new angle, but you have some nice concepts here - the brightness, the idea that the shadow is more loveable.
Second comment is the meter, which I would say is not limerick. Think of 3/4 time musical bars. I have just counted in my head, and there should be 13 such bars, arranged 3 3 2 2 3. To show what I mean, here's an instant example which means nothing, but sticks rigidly to the meter and rhythm
There was a - young fellow - called Peter
Who had a - godmother - named Rita
When out on - excursions
They tried dif - ferent versions
Of sitting - upon a - two-seater
nirupama,
The case of seeing images in a way which will take the reader to its unknown pastures, is an age old practice being done by writers. The fact is that how you approach and manifest it. The craft seems to be at its peak.
Carry on.....
Hey there! I'm a 19 year old student from India.
Feel free to comment on my works after reading them. Constructive criticism is always appreciated. more..