Honest reviews and ideas are welcome. This is my first time doing something like this. Will appreciate any improvement ideas or tips to get better at this. Thankyou.
My Review
Would you like to review this Poem? Login | Register
I think you have some really solid work here that could be amazing with a bit of revision. First, your final stanza is really strong, especially the last two lines. I would suggest on the last line using only one period rather than two. There's a lot more strength in a definitive end than there is in the unsure trail-off you've given us right now.
Another suggestion I have is read through the poem again and make sure you've punctuated properly. Especially between "I miss you" (stanza 1) and "Look at these lovers" (stanza 2). Right now, without a definitive breaking point between the two, they kind of run together and it gets a bit muddled.
A final thing to think about is your third stanza. It's definitely the weakest point of your poem. It doesn't seem to "fit" with the rest of the poem and it all seems kind of cliche and a bit corny.
Altogether, you have a strong base here. I hope this review helped, happy revising!
Posted 7 Years Ago
2 of 2 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
Hey. Thanks a ton! This was really helpful. I have a better picture in my head now . Will surely mak.. read moreHey. Thanks a ton! This was really helpful. I have a better picture in my head now . Will surely make some changes here. Please do review my other pieces too.
Love.
7 Years Ago
Hey I made a few changes. Mostly tried to work on the parts you pointed out. Do go through it and le.. read moreHey I made a few changes. Mostly tried to work on the parts you pointed out. Do go through it and let me know how it looks now.
7 Years Ago
The only glaring problem I see left is the exclamation mark after "vanity". It makes a fragment out .. read moreThe only glaring problem I see left is the exclamation mark after "vanity". It makes a fragment out of your last line. "What use is vanity when I don't have you anymore" is all one thought/sentence, and breaking it up with punctuation really doesn't make sense. Other than that, it's looking good!
You feel I should replace it with a question mark? Or just leave it be.. without any punctuation?
7 Years Ago
After "vanity" there should be no punctuation, you should just let the line turn. After "anymore" a .. read moreAfter "vanity" there should be no punctuation, you should just let the line turn. After "anymore" a question mark would probably be better but you could get away with leaving it as a period as well.
There are some feelings here which you've articulated really beautifully. Poetry is all about evoking empathy for the reader, and you've certainly succeeded here. I enjoyed this, keep writing!
The beginning of this poem would sound better if you started with "when i close my eyes" or "I close my eyes". It would make more sense. Otherwise i think this poem has true meaning to it and I think your an amazing poet. Keep working!!
Posted 7 Years Ago
7 Years Ago
Hey Justina! Thank you so much for your kind words. It really is a boost to my confidence :) I will.. read moreHey Justina! Thank you so much for your kind words. It really is a boost to my confidence :) I will surely see what I can do about the changes you suggested. Thank you!
Hi Nema. This is a good piece of writing. I just noticed that you could make some changes to it. Like in the first line, i feel like putting "I" close my eyes, "I" look at those lovers, makes the poem sound better. The absence of the I makes it seem like you are talking to someone next to you. If that's what you were going for then it's okay. In all, nice work.
Posted 7 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
Hi Avia! Thanks for the review. I've skipped the 'I' because there's a "my" in the first line which .. read moreHi Avia! Thanks for the review. I've skipped the 'I' because there's a "my" in the first line which I feel does the work? I just thought it be a good idea to leave this to the readers imagination.
Does that sound okay? Also please do let me know of there's anything else that can be done to improve the poem. It's really helpful.
I think you have some really solid work here that could be amazing with a bit of revision. First, your final stanza is really strong, especially the last two lines. I would suggest on the last line using only one period rather than two. There's a lot more strength in a definitive end than there is in the unsure trail-off you've given us right now.
Another suggestion I have is read through the poem again and make sure you've punctuated properly. Especially between "I miss you" (stanza 1) and "Look at these lovers" (stanza 2). Right now, without a definitive breaking point between the two, they kind of run together and it gets a bit muddled.
A final thing to think about is your third stanza. It's definitely the weakest point of your poem. It doesn't seem to "fit" with the rest of the poem and it all seems kind of cliche and a bit corny.
Altogether, you have a strong base here. I hope this review helped, happy revising!
Posted 7 Years Ago
2 of 2 people found this review constructive.
7 Years Ago
Hey. Thanks a ton! This was really helpful. I have a better picture in my head now . Will surely mak.. read moreHey. Thanks a ton! This was really helpful. I have a better picture in my head now . Will surely make some changes here. Please do review my other pieces too.
Love.
7 Years Ago
Hey I made a few changes. Mostly tried to work on the parts you pointed out. Do go through it and le.. read moreHey I made a few changes. Mostly tried to work on the parts you pointed out. Do go through it and let me know how it looks now.
7 Years Ago
The only glaring problem I see left is the exclamation mark after "vanity". It makes a fragment out .. read moreThe only glaring problem I see left is the exclamation mark after "vanity". It makes a fragment out of your last line. "What use is vanity when I don't have you anymore" is all one thought/sentence, and breaking it up with punctuation really doesn't make sense. Other than that, it's looking good!
You feel I should replace it with a question mark? Or just leave it be.. without any punctuation?
7 Years Ago
After "vanity" there should be no punctuation, you should just let the line turn. After "anymore" a .. read moreAfter "vanity" there should be no punctuation, you should just let the line turn. After "anymore" a question mark would probably be better but you could get away with leaving it as a period as well.
24. Dentist. Been in love with writing (esp poems) and reading for as long as I can remember. Never tried publishing anywhere. And no idea how good/bad my work is. Looking for some advice and ideas. S.. more..