Personal preference, but I find 'primordial' to have a stronger connotation, and to roll off the tongue better... Perhaps see how you like it instead of primeval? You also use weep twice, and on a poem of this length (and consistent theme of melancholy), a repetition of a word such as weep is almost always a bad idea. Perhaps change the first one to 'laments'?. I would also recommend removing the unnecessary words from the beginning of each line, delete everything up to and including 'the'; I think it really holds this back, the way that each line's descriptions use 'the'. Anyway, I like the concept behind this one, and it is really summed up well in your last line, as if the whole of creation is stumbling, and the earth as one will collapse.
Posted 10 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
10 Years Ago
Thank you for the input and your review. I think "primordial" could have worked; and, I agree "lamen.. read moreThank you for the input and your review. I think "primordial" could have worked; and, I agree "lament" might have been a better word for one of the "weeps." It's too late now, though. This poem is the pivot of a Poetry Challenge from which other poets pulled a line and composed their own poem on the theme of global climate change.
However, I disagree about the use of "The" which was a deliberate device to drive the point that this tragedy is repeated everywhere, to give a repetitive feel to each different line.
Thank you. I'm sorry it confused you. It's meant to be ambiguous. The poem is about global climate c.. read moreThank you. I'm sorry it confused you. It's meant to be ambiguous. The poem is about global climate change.
Sad and sorrowful image defining mother earth...yet so delicately expressed and beautifully penned...I tried reading your poem "winter"...nothing was on the page?
Posted 10 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
10 Years Ago
I know. I discovered that yesterday. There are two "Winter" posts. I tried to post it as an image I'.. read moreI know. I discovered that yesterday. There are two "Winter" posts. I tried to post it as an image I'd made of the PDF. I tried to post the PDF. But, this site automatically sizes images, holding them to a minimum. So, the image was too small. There's another, text-only post of "Winter." Try here: http://www.writerscafe.org/writing/MomzillaNC/1411162/
Personal preference, but I find 'primordial' to have a stronger connotation, and to roll off the tongue better... Perhaps see how you like it instead of primeval? You also use weep twice, and on a poem of this length (and consistent theme of melancholy), a repetition of a word such as weep is almost always a bad idea. Perhaps change the first one to 'laments'?. I would also recommend removing the unnecessary words from the beginning of each line, delete everything up to and including 'the'; I think it really holds this back, the way that each line's descriptions use 'the'. Anyway, I like the concept behind this one, and it is really summed up well in your last line, as if the whole of creation is stumbling, and the earth as one will collapse.
Posted 10 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
10 Years Ago
Thank you for the input and your review. I think "primordial" could have worked; and, I agree "lamen.. read moreThank you for the input and your review. I think "primordial" could have worked; and, I agree "lament" might have been a better word for one of the "weeps." It's too late now, though. This poem is the pivot of a Poetry Challenge from which other poets pulled a line and composed their own poem on the theme of global climate change.
However, I disagree about the use of "The" which was a deliberate device to drive the point that this tragedy is repeated everywhere, to give a repetitive feel to each different line.
It is truly sad that we human cannot maintain
a harmonious relationship with the other members of nature...
Posted 10 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
10 Years Ago
Very sad, indeed. And sadder still that so many can still delude themselves and continue to believe .. read moreVery sad, indeed. And sadder still that so many can still delude themselves and continue to believe we're not the cause of global climate change, refusing to adapt and try to make things better. We were put here to be stewards of creation. When we face the creator, some distant day, what account can we possible give of our stewardship?
And that you have done with finesse..........good luck with the challenge!!
10 Years Ago
Thank you. Actually, it was my challenge. My group, "Poetry Challenge" is supposed to use at least o.. read moreThank you. Actually, it was my challenge. My group, "Poetry Challenge" is supposed to use at least one of my lines and pen an ambiguous poem of their own on the themes of anti-pollution and/or global climate change: but they cannot use specific terms of the themes in their poem.
10 Years Ago
"Lost In Your Calidity" is my offering for the color challenge of that group.
Thank you, I'm glad you liked it. When will your offering to my challenge be up?
10 Years Ago
soon. i an currently trying to survive my mid-semester exams. but i am very excited about the group .. read moresoon. i an currently trying to survive my mid-semester exams. but i am very excited about the group and challenges. it was very much needed.
10 Years Ago
I'm rather enjoying it myself. I really enjoyed the color challenge too.
A melancholy whirl upon the earth indeed, you've written it so eloquently.
Posted 10 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
10 Years Ago
Thank you. I hope I'll soon see your offering as you take up my poetry challenge…
10 Years Ago
This was a challenge?
10 Years Ago
Yes… you joined my group "Poetry Challenge." The challenge is posted in the group forum, with the .. read moreYes… you joined my group "Poetry Challenge." The challenge is posted in the group forum, with the rules. Someone else has already issued a second challenge too.
10 Years Ago
I did, haha, must need another cuppa coffee this morning!
If you read my work and comment, I'll return the favor on your work. I'm not adding new friends nor accepting read requests.
I am a classically trained artist and was an award-winning graphic desig.. more..