in this poem, Mary is at Elizabeth's home, Elizabeth has given birth to John, and Mary is getting to know him. I need some advice with this one, wording, title, etc.
You capture elements of John the Baptist's later character - the fiercely uncompromising message, the wilderness and desert storms... and of the tender heart of Mary, anticipating the experience to come, with its potential for joy and for grief...
I wasn't sure of the point of the "..." I seemed like an unnecessary gap...
Good use of simple verse structure to sustain the scene and create the atmosphere
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
thanks, I'll rethink the "..." I really appreciate the time you are taking for these poems, Jibey. .. read morethanks, I'll rethink the "..." I really appreciate the time you are taking for these poems, Jibey. Very very helpful.
You capture elements of John the Baptist's later character - the fiercely uncompromising message, the wilderness and desert storms... and of the tender heart of Mary, anticipating the experience to come, with its potential for joy and for grief...
I wasn't sure of the point of the "..." I seemed like an unnecessary gap...
Good use of simple verse structure to sustain the scene and create the atmosphere
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
thanks, I'll rethink the "..." I really appreciate the time you are taking for these poems, Jibey. .. read morethanks, I'll rethink the "..." I really appreciate the time you are taking for these poems, Jibey. Very very helpful.
I absolutely love the way you are doing these poems! Your special way with the wording and heartfelt way you seem to insert yourself into these people and feel them moves me every time. I think this is beautifully done. I would only say that I think "Untamed Eyes" would be my preference, but either way you have done what you set out to do....again. Stunning!
Your empathetic insight has spanned the centuries to create something true, something ageless, something utterly lovely.
The worthiness of this work can almost not be overstated.
A virtual triumph!
("Untamed Eyes" does, however, seem, to me, Mary, to be the better grammatical choice.)
I thought about that too, I go back and forth with it, not sure why. Thanks for your review.
12 Years Ago
Suppose it just comes down to the fact that "Untamed" sounded a bit better to me. I rarely make the.. read moreSuppose it just comes down to the fact that "Untamed" sounded a bit better to me. I rarely make the mistake of making such suggestions.
On the other hand, of all the things I said in my review, THIS is what you key on?
You're funny.
12 Years Ago
I am so grateful for the review, Frank, especially when you picked up on the timelessness of the poe.. read moreI am so grateful for the review, Frank, especially when you picked up on the timelessness of the poem. That is ultimately the goal of my "Mary" poems.
thought this was truly wonderful writing - the thought sprang to me, you could use 'wilderness' instead of wildness' and play on that theme. Maybe even the idea of Mary being pierced through with sorrow brought in. But to be honest it's all good.
I think that your wording is perfect as it is, giving clear imagery and thought. As to the title, there are a few phrases with in the poem that stood out as possible alternatives, should you still wish to the title.
1. God's Grace
2.Untaimed Eyes
As always, these are just suggestions, feel free to ignore as you wish.
I am total geek, optimist, hopeless romantic child of God. I love poetry! I was a high school science teacher for many years, but at the present time I work as a math tutor at a local community coll.. more..