Ticci Toby Scenarios (Not Finished)

A Story by Jessica Jones

This is a boyfriend senario about a creepypasta known as Ticci Toby. If you do not know the origin of this person, or at least what a creepypasta is, please do not judge harshly. **Y/N is your name.*

(When you meet him)

You're balling your eyes out, running down the street.

The bullies are still chasing you, calling you names and throwing rocks at you. Your mom just had to make you wear those dorky new shoes to school today.

You tripped and fell to the ground with a thud. "Ah..oh s**t!" You try to get back up only to see feet next to your head. You realize that you in an alley, which means..no way out.

"Haha awe look at little Y/N!" they teased.

They started to kick you. "This is what you get for rolling your eyes when we talk to you..you little b***h!"

You were crying and clutching your stomach trying not to feel the kicks.

After a few more kicks and laughs you hear two thuds and the kids yelling in pain.

Your hands still clutching your stomach, eyes shut tight, and hoping you won’t go home with a black eye this time.

You open your eyes slowly only to see a shadow standing over you holding their hand down to you. You look a little closer to see that the boy who helped save you was none other than Ticci Toby. The creepypasta that you would read stories about on the internet.

"Are you okay? Did they break anything? Can you t..t...talk" He said with a little tick. You look over to see bloody bodies of what used to be the bullies that were beating you up.

He holds his hand down to help you up.

"Here let me h..help you up." You take his hand hesitant, thinking he may still kill you. I mean come on he's a stone cold killer for goodness sake.

"You know who i am d..d..don't you? That's why you're quiet and also why you hesitated." You nod your head slowly.

"Can you speak? Or are you just shy." He asks concerned.

This really got to you. How could a killer, a boy who supposedly doesn't have feelings, who kills people in cold blood, be concerned for me?

"I'm..f..fine. Really I am. They do that a lot. See.." You say showing him the bruises on your arms and face, ever some on your stomach. "It was my fault for wearing these shoes to school.”

"What is wrong with those p..people, well you won't need to worry about them anymore b..because they are dead now." he says showing you the dead bodies.

"Yeah..i guess, but thank you. Wait..why haven't you killed me yet?" You asked looking at the killer.

"I know what it's like to be b..bullied for what you are and what you have, or things you have t..t..that you wish you d..didn't" He said. "Plus, i thought a pretty girl like you shouldn't be treated like that. W..what's your name?"

You blush at that compliment and say "My name is Y/N. And your Ticci Toby, right?"

"You can call me Toby. We should talk again some time, but i have to go. See ya Y/N!"

You wave goodbye as you see the boy disappear in the alley. You hurry and rush home.

(Becoming Friends)

For the next few weeks, when you walk home from school, Toby walks with you. He says it’s for “protection”.

“You know, I can walk home by myself. Its fine..really. You don’t have to protect me.” you said.

“No..it’s r..really not a bother. I d..don’t mind.” he replied. You felt like he thought you were weak. And, other times you thought he was just being nice until he decides to kill you. I mean come on killers can be liars too.

“Y/N, you’re m..my friend right?” he asked as he stopped with a twitch. “If you’d like then yes.” you replied. “I’ve never really h..had a friend b..before.” he says looking down.

“Hey! Don’t feel bad..i don’t have very many myself. Besides you, i only have 2 other friends.” you said. He looks at you for a second. “Really? I would think that you have m..many friends.” He says turning his head.

“Yeah..I’m not really a social person as you saw from the first time we met.” you say shrugging your shoulders. “Well..we can be friends r..r..right?” he asks innocently. You looked into his eyes..or goggles more or less. You can tell that inside that stone cold hatchet throwing serial killer, was an innocent boy who only wants to have friends. You know what it feels like to want friends. He can’t help what he has, and you understand that. You really do want to be friends with him. “Yes.” you replied with a smile. You continued your walk, as you continued to talk to one-another. “Slenderman is a little hesitant of m..me hanging out with you. He thinks it may not be a good idea for me to be friends with another human. I told him about y..you though, but he wants t..t..to meet you. He is like my father..in a sense. He took me in, ya..ya know. He is just looking out for me, and the other p..pastas.” he explains. “Yeah, I understand. Well, if you take me to meet him, I want you to promise me one thing.” you say looking at him. “Okay.” he says. “If they decide to kill me, DO NOT tell them not to. Just let them kill me. They will lose all trust for you if you stick up for me.” “No! I will not let them k..kill you. You’re my only friend!” He protests. You grab his hand and look into his eye..or goggles. “Please. I do not want you to get hurt or lose more people just because of me. Trust me. It will all be okay.” you smile reassuring. He shakes his head yes. You let go of his hand and continue your walk.

He looks down the rest of the time. “You can meet him tomorrow but may I ask a favor?” he says.

“C..can I sleep over tonight. I will sleep on the floor its just, if they do k..kill you, I wanna at least hang out w..with you one last time.” he says looking down. You smiled.

“Of course you can.” He looks up and walks with you all the way home. You guys hung out the whole night, you played video games. You had pizza and even watched a movie together. You have to admit you had a great time with Toby. When it was time to sleep Toby laid on the floor like he promised, but he had a night terror in the middle of the night. He had a dream that all the pasts were ripping you apart. You let him sleep in your bed the rest of the night. You let him hold you as you fell asleep in his arms. Nothing happened. You guys are only friends. Well at least that’s what you think.

(When he gets feelings for you)

The next morning you woke up to Toby eating waffles on the other side of your room. He didn’t notice you, so you decided to just..look at him for a minute. He looked like a little kid eating breakfast before his first day of school. “He’s so adorable” you thought. After realizing what you had thought, you shook your head and coughed.

“Oh, hey! G..goodmorning!” he says as he walks over to you.

“Good morning to you too.” you smiled. You then looked at the plate of waffles, and began to think. “Wait..Toby where did you get those waffles?” you asked pointing at the plate.

“I got them from the freezer.” he replied. You loved waffles yourself. After telling you where he got them you realized that those were the last of the waffles you had in the house.

“Oh, well we’ll have to go get some more later. Those were the last of them” you said getting out of bed.

“Oh, I’m sorry. I didn’t know. D..did you want one? Should I buy m..more? I’ll never eat your waffles again if you’d like.” He spoke in some what a panic.

“No..no its fine Toby. I don’t mind. As long as my parents didn’t see you its okay.” you replied trying to calm him.

“A..are you sure?” he asks. “Yes. I’m sure.” you replied.

You looked at the clock It was about 10:30am. You looked at Toby.

“Are we going to meet Slenderman today?” you asked. He got a little less cheerful. “Oh..yeah, i guess we can now if you’d like.”

“Yeah. Let me go get dressed. You can finish your waffles in here Toby.” you said walking out the door.

About 10 mins later you come back and you’re ready to go. You and Toby walk out of the house and headed into the woods.

You were pretty deep into the woods. I mean you couldn’t even see your house, or any houses for that matter. You started to hear static and your head was hurting terribly.

You fell to the ground. “Ahh” you said clutching your head.

“Stop! Slender she’s had enough! STOP!” Toby yelled. Everything went fuzzy and you passed out.

**4 hours later**

You wake up to see Toby standing over you.

“Ah, the child is awake at last.” you heard a voice say.

“Wh..what happened? Dad? Is that you? Mom? Ow!” you asked as you held your head and sat up. You sit up to see a 7 to 9 foot tall man who wore a black and white suit. It was Slenderman. Toby backs away from you. “Are you okay?” he asks.

“Yeah I’m fine, My head just hurts.” you said. You got out of the bed and Slenderman walked over to you.

“Hello my child. Toby has said much about you and the other pastas would like to meet you.” he gesturing at the door.

“Thank you sir.” you said. You walk out and also head down the stairs to see a bunch of teens in the living room. You see a blonde boy dressed as Link from Majora’s Mask, playing video games on the floor. That was obviously BEN drowned. You see a pale kid with black singed hair and a cut smile into his cheeks, wiping a knife. That was Jeff the killer. You see a black and white clown next to him eating candy. That was Laughing Jack. The others must have been in the kitchen or out killing.

“Children come and meet our guest.” Slenderman says loud.

Jeff gets off the couch and is now face to face with you. “Hmm, you are almost as beautiful as myself.” he says with a grin. You blushed as you heard Toby growl silently.

“Woah, is that a chef's knife from the Knife Shark T.V. collection?!” you said looking at the knife in Jeff’s hand. Jeff’s eyes got wider and his smile got bigger (If that was even possible).

“Yeah! It is, i got it about 2 weeks ago.” he says.

“Nice!” you say. Jeff nods and walks back to the couch. You walk over to BEN.

“Um, Hi BEN.” you say.

BEN of course didn’t even look away from his video game. He was playing Call of Duty Black Ops 2, one of your favorite games. He was 1v1ing a kid on the map Nuketown.

You kneeled down next to him. “You know if you go into the garage and look slightly through the wall and the house you can kill as they are coming out of spawn.” you say pointing at the T.V.

“Yeah..sure.” he says.

“Go ahead and try.” you said. He did as you instructed and got a 4 kill streak.

“Damn...you were right.” he smiles. “Hey, we should play sometime.” he says.

“Yeah that would be fun.” you replied with a smile.

Laughing Jack walked over to you and held out his hand which was full of colorful candy. You looked at his hand hesitantly.

“Want some candy? Hahahehehe!” he giggled.

“No poisoned candy Jack! This is a guest, and she is very kind.” Slenderman says.

Slenderman walks over to you and gestures you to go into the kitchen. You smile at Jack and say “I have candy at home, I’ll bring it next time and we can share if you want.” He smiles at that and sits back on the couch.

You walk in to see Eyeless Jack, Masky, Hoodie, Rake, and Sally. You looked over to Slenderman.

“Do any of the girl killers live here sir?” you asked politely.

“No, considering most of them are enemies to the boys, the only one who lives here is Sally, and that is because she is my child. I took her in 2 years ago when she was only 8. She had no one and now she has a family.” he explains.

You smile. “That’s wonderful.” Sally then runs up to you.

“Do you want to play with me?” she grabs your hand.

“Of course sweetie, but later okay? I need to talk to Mr. Slenderman and the other guys.” you say smiling.

She smiles and says “Okay!” she walks out into the living room.

“She’s so adorable!” you smiled.

Eyeless Jack walks over to you. “Can I have your Kidneys?” he asks.

“Um, you can have one i guess..” you say looking back at Toby and Slenderman.

“No Jack!” said Toby. “You cannot have one of her kidneys.” he says pushing you past him.

Jack just shrugged and went back to eating his ‘food’ at table.

You see a platter of cheesecake on the kitchen table.

“Oo may I have some cheesecake? It’s my favorite dessert!” you say as you walk over to the table.

Then Maskey comes over and says “It’s mine too.” You look at him and he is almost personal space close, but you didn’t mind.

“Awesome! Well may I have a slice?” you asked politely.

“Y..yeah sure” he said handing you a plate. You ate the cheesecake with Masky. After you were finished The Rake walks over to you.

He runs his claw along your face and you tense up. You see Toby try to run at him but Slenderman holds him back. Putting his tentacles around Toby’s mouth guard so he cannot speak.

“Just wait child.” Slenderman says calmly.

“Soo..you are Toby’s friend heh? Heheheh” he says.

“Yes, I am.” you replied calmly. You were scared, but for Toby’s sake, you couldn’t show him. You had to be strong..for him.

“Hmm, your flesh does look..appetizing.” he says licking his lips. You looked at him. “You can’t have it. I’m sorry, but it is mine.” you reply. The Rake was taken back by this. No one ever tells the Rake no. He smiles and looks back at Toby. He cuts open your cheek with one clean swipe and blood drips to the floor. Toby freaks out and tries to break free from Slenderman, but to no avail. He wasn’t going anywhere.

Your face remains motionless. Your eyes showed the pain though.

“She is a tough one eh Slender?” Rake says walking back. “Yes. Yes she is.” Slenderman replies.

After the Rake is out of the kitchen you grabbed your cheek and tried not to cry.

Slenderman walks over to you and hands you a wet towel. “I am sorry child, it’s just precaution.” he says. “It’s fine.” you replied as you held the towel to your cheek.

“I have watched you, ever since you met Toby that day. I saw when you would talk to him, I saw when you wouldn’t. I heard what you said to him yesterday. When you said you would give your life just so he may stay here with us. I heard your thoughts while Rake was talking to you. You were terrified but stayed calm. You really care about Toby. I understand that, and I admire it. I will allow you to visit the house anytime you want, just do not start trouble and all will be fine. Understand child?” Slenderman explains.

“Yes, I understand sir. Thank you.” you smiled.

After Everyone left the kitchen Toby walks up and hugs you tight. You smiled and hugged back.

“I told you not to worry. No matter what, I will always be here.” Toby then takes off his mouth guard and kisses your cheek softly. You blushed.

“T..Thank you Y/N” he says as he puts the mouth guard back on. Toby didn’t want to admit that he liked you. He wanted to wait for the right time to tell you.

(When he asks you out)

You woke up the next morning to the smell of waffles. Toby must be in the kitchen. You smiled. Suddenly you remembered that you still live with your parents. Your eyes widened.

You ran down the stairs into the kitchen.

“Toby!” you whispered. “You can’t be in here. My parents may see you!”

“I..its okay Y/N. They left for the w..weekend. They l..left you this note.” he says handing you the note.

It read.

‘Y/N Your father and I had to go visit your grandmother. We decided that we did not need to drag you along. We are trusting you to stay home alone for the weekend without the house falling apart. We will be home in 2 days. Love you! Stay safe! -Mom.’

“Great!” you smiled.

You got some waffles on your plate and started eating them. You looked up to see Toby staring at you.

“May I help you?” you giggled as you wiped your mouth.

“You’re so beautiful.” he says. You blushed deeply.

“Thank you Toby.” you smiled. You finished your waffles in about 5 mins. They were delicious!

You got up to clean your plate, and you felt arms wrap around your waist. You got stiff. Was Toby hugging you from behind?

You were spun around and brought into a kiss. You were so tense at first but found yourself kissing back. He let go of the kiss and you realized he has both his mouth guard and his goggles were off.

You were out of words.

“T..toby..” you stuttered.

“Y/N, I have liked you ever since I met you a year ago.” he says. “I know you probably don’t feel the same way, but I can’t keep living while keeping this a secret.” he lets go of you and looks down. You realized that he didn’t tick, he didn’t stutter.

“I understand if you feel uncomfortable and do not want to talk to me anymore.” he looks down.

You walked up to him and lifted his chin.

“Toby, I have had a crush on you for a while now. Why else would I risk my life for you?” you smiled.

He leaned in and kissed you softly.

“W..will you be mine?” he asked.

You smiled.

“Yes.”

He smiled. And lifted you in a hug and spun you around. You laughed. ‘I wonder if this is a good idea’ you thought to yourself.

(When he’s loving)

You woke up in Toby’s arms. You have been dating for 4 months. Toby has met your parents and they LOVE him! They said he was allowed over anytime he wanted. I told them his back story and they have seen the sweet things he does for you. You open your eyes and feel his arms around your waist.

“Good morning my love.” He whispers in your ear. You smiled. He lets go of you and you sit up rubbing your eyes to see that he has a huge teddy bear in his arms. You gasped.

“Oh my gosh! It’s so cute!” You giggled. “Just like you babe.” he says.

You couldn’t hide your smile, you couldn’t hide the blush either. As you looked closer you saw that the bear has necklaces around it’s neck. He set the bear next to you and took the necklaces off of the bear.

“They are matching, now I am always with you, even when I am out.”

You began to tear up. Happy tears of course.

“Babe! Don’t cry.” He says as he begins to hold you.

“This is the sweetest thing that anyone has ever done for me! I don’t understand why out of everyone in the world you chose me, but god I am so glad that you did. I..I love you..”

After saying this you covered your mouth.

“I’m sorry, I didn’t mean for that to-”

You were cut off by lips smashing into yours. You were wide eyed but kissed back. You laid back as he laid on top of you, kissing you continuously.

“I have been waiting for you to say that for more than a year babe. I love you so much!”

He kissed you again. All you could think of, is how whenever he kissed you, everything was okay. Everything was right with the world. You didn’t have any problems, no depression, stress, bullies, just love.”

“I love you so much too!”

You giggled as he kissed your neck and you realized that this was the best thing that had ever happened to you. HE was the best thing that ever happen to you. You sat up and held the necklace. He goes behind you and puts it on.

“Thank you babe. Thank you for making me the happiest girl in the world.”

“Thank you for saying yes.” He says kissing your cheek.