In this piece, you are simply telling, not really showing. In writing short poems, you should be more of an imagist rather than of a narrator. Although you were able to express what was or still is in your heart, you should, at least, think what the readers will make of this piece.
I assume that you posted this not just for yourself to express what you feel but also for others to read and perhaps relate with this piece. This time I'm talking about connecting the piece with the reader. Having read this poem, I think you were so immersed in expressing rather than sharing that's why this work of yours turned out to be something that is very personal. How about trying to detach yourself from the poem even just a bit? This process requires using a different perspective. Try doing this: imagine that you are not you and then look at the real Simphonia or at her actual experiences. From this point, try to write. It's like putting your "non-Simphonia self" into the real Simphonia's own shoes. By doing such, I think the poem will become relatable. I hope you get my point.
Also, try to be not so literal and so simple as far as the use of language is concerned. Doing this will make your writing sound more poetic. Read this poem of yours again and you will find it so plain and simple and not so poetic at all (except for the rhyming). Some lines even sound so forcedly rhymed. Try to work on that as well.
I'm not saying that this one is a trash. I just know that your next poems will be a lot better than this one, right?
My best wishes to you.
- sir joe
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
wow, sir joe THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'll work on that! :)
You're most welcome, my dear Simphonia. I am just honest about what I've made of your poem. A critic.. read moreYou're most welcome, my dear Simphonia. I am just honest about what I've made of your poem. A critic should do what he must. Whenever I see something negative, I feel I have to say it [in the right way].
I think the simplicity is what makes this piece, my friend, like a child relating about a friend. If anything, what I see is a 'flow' problem, it doesn't read smoothly, but it's very simplicity is what makes it so cute. Big smile here.
There is a subtle hint of heartbreak and disappointment within this sweet write. But most of all, I felt the love flowing regardless of the broken promise... Nicely done!
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
how did you know there was a hint of heartbreak? OMG. You're right Robbie! :)
In this piece, you are simply telling, not really showing. In writing short poems, you should be more of an imagist rather than of a narrator. Although you were able to express what was or still is in your heart, you should, at least, think what the readers will make of this piece.
I assume that you posted this not just for yourself to express what you feel but also for others to read and perhaps relate with this piece. This time I'm talking about connecting the piece with the reader. Having read this poem, I think you were so immersed in expressing rather than sharing that's why this work of yours turned out to be something that is very personal. How about trying to detach yourself from the poem even just a bit? This process requires using a different perspective. Try doing this: imagine that you are not you and then look at the real Simphonia or at her actual experiences. From this point, try to write. It's like putting your "non-Simphonia self" into the real Simphonia's own shoes. By doing such, I think the poem will become relatable. I hope you get my point.
Also, try to be not so literal and so simple as far as the use of language is concerned. Doing this will make your writing sound more poetic. Read this poem of yours again and you will find it so plain and simple and not so poetic at all (except for the rhyming). Some lines even sound so forcedly rhymed. Try to work on that as well.
I'm not saying that this one is a trash. I just know that your next poems will be a lot better than this one, right?
My best wishes to you.
- sir joe
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
wow, sir joe THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'll work on that! :)
You're most welcome, my dear Simphonia. I am just honest about what I've made of your poem. A critic.. read moreYou're most welcome, my dear Simphonia. I am just honest about what I've made of your poem. A critic should do what he must. Whenever I see something negative, I feel I have to say it [in the right way].