An observation on the big city disease of refusing to get involved. Sometimes others need your help. Sometimes you need theirs. You can make a difference!
My Review
Would you like to review this Poem? Login | Register
Not being a big fan of repetition, I found that 50% of a fairly lengthy poem using the same line over & over . . . it brought on a little eye-glazing-over in stretches. Even a tweak here & there, to break up the monotony & add some variance would make a big difference. I like your message & the way you hammer it home repetitively, which lends itself to some type of music, with a simple beat-like rhythm. My opinion is that there are many of these types of people who instantly run for danger instead of away from it. But not everyone is like that & not everyone could be a help in such a situation. Lots of people are barely holding themselves together against dire challenges. I'm not in agreement that everyone should be guilt-tripped into hero action. We each have our strengths & it's better to encourage people to do what they're good at. And we can also celebrate the heros that jump into the fire without hesitation. But I do appreciate the spots in your message where you're saying people just don't want to get involved or they're basically too lazy or uncaring to get involved. These kinds of people could use some prodding, as you do in your poem (((HUGS))) Fondly, Margie
Thank you, Margie, for your review; constructive and thoughtful, as always. I know your feelings abo.. read moreThank you, Margie, for your review; constructive and thoughtful, as always. I know your feelings about repetition because we have had this discussion before. I also know that you don't make much use of it in your own excellent work. It is just a point on which we can agree to disagree. I regard it as just another tool to make use of when I deem it appropriate. In this instance it is simply the hammer to drive the nail!
I agree with all of your points about the message, and would add that i expected this to be controversial when I wrote it. But you will note that I wrote it anyway. I believe this is a dark corner of city life that needed a light shone into it. I am certainly not advocating that fools should rush in where angels fear to tread.
Perhaps I could give you an example of the kind of thing I am talking by using an instance from my own life.
This occurred in London, England. I was on my way to a meeting during the rush hour, crossing London bridge at the time. I was recovering from a serious illness at the time and halfway across the bridge I was struck by a wave of pain so agonizing that my brain shut things down and I collapsed unconscious on the sidewalk. I don't know how long I was out for - it might have been two minutes, it might have been ten. When I recovered consciousness people were stepping over my body because it was blocking the sidewalk, but not one single person stopped to offer assistance! I was left to struggle to my feet on my own. As it happened I was right as rain after a five minute rest, but I could just as easily have been dying. That is the kind of situation where anybody could have helped, but no one did.
I could quote several other examples of similar conduct, but I think that one instance is sufficient to make my point.
I hope you had a good Easter.
6 Years Ago
Thanks for sharing more about your point of view . . . all your observations are well taken! *smile*
I loved the repetition in this poem, as it conveys so strongly the cause and effect of his schooling which was never to interfere, and how each time he walked away it took a bit of himself with him, a very effective poem on how each person can make a difference if they ignore ideas that we are individuals and not community
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thanks again, Madeira. I love the way you have expressed your understanding of the poem, particularl.. read moreThanks again, Madeira. I love the way you have expressed your understanding of the poem, particularly 'and how each time he walked away it took a bit of himself with him'. YYou have captured exactly what I was trying to say!
I agree with your logic in the poem. People seem blind to the needs of others. If we assisted someone. Maybe they could succeed. Thank you my friend for sharing the outstanding poetry.
Coyote
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thank you, Coyote. You are right - it is the willful indifference that I find so horrifying.
His body walked on,
But it was just a shell,
His body walked long,
In it's living Hell.
You're words here really struck home to me.
It's so true though, we all have times in our life when we should have stayed. We should've been there for those who needed it the most. You're words here are powerful and I know that you're a very talented author/writer.
The flow was great!
Keep up the great work my friend!
Your friend,
C. Lee Battaglia
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thank you, Lee. I'm glad you enjoyed it. And thank you again for the compliment! :)
Good moral running through this.
We always think to ourselves, someone else will deal with it.
But hindsight is a wonderful thing. Doesn't bring back the dead though.
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
That's the problem in a nutshell alright, Paul. Thanks.
have to agree with the Barley babe about the repetition ..though i do also appreciate how it works to hammer a point ..i took it in a more general sense tho...and people walking past and/or over lifeless people on the sidewalks and alleys happens all the time in the larger metropolitan areas where deep drug addictions and crime are greater people are maybe less prone to "get involved" ... but there is no excuse .. especially today when cell phones are already attached to ones lips and ears .. just a simple 911 and a clear report may be enough to save a life ... i think of the "Kitty" Genovese rape and murder in the 60s Chicago ... the attack took over 30 minutes while multiple people heard her screams and watched "in horror" as she was brutally stabbed and killed ... no one called nor tried to help her ... her attacker was however interrupted by lights coming on and windows being opened ..so he was scared off .. but returned to continue the attack three times before she was silenced ... i hear your message loud and clear and just recounting that event puts a stop to my heart beat and that big question ...what would i have done ... i am glad i have not been tested by an event ... but i sure hope i would do something ... strong voice ... easy rhythm ... your own experience must have been life changing .. thank you for sharing
E.
Thanks for your review, Noodleman. Your example is a very good extreme example of the syndrome! But .. read moreThanks for your review, Noodleman. Your example is a very good extreme example of the syndrome! But no, my experience was not life chsnging, simply because I had learned that particular lesson long before that incident. I should also add that I have several experiences where my life has been saved by total strangers, so there are people out there who are prepared to get involved. Unfortunately they are a very small minority.
6 Years Ago
yes...so true ...we have uplifting examples of courage and honesty every day .. the press simply see.. read moreyes...so true ...we have uplifting examples of courage and honesty every day .. the press simply seems to think those kinds of things aren't usually new worthy :(
6 Years Ago
You're right, they only want to print the bad stuff!
This poem is something that speaks to me on a personal level. I've experienced the feeling of walking away. It may feel like a victory to have walked away from that bully that one time. But it was a prolonged defeat. If you walk away instead of dealing with your problems, you'll only extend the length of the problem. All in all, this poem has a nice message, however I found it quite repetitive as another review said. It was still a good one though.
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thank you, KB. The psychic trauma lasts forever, doesn't it? Unfortunately it is impossible to go ba.. read moreThank you, KB. The psychic trauma lasts forever, doesn't it? Unfortunately it is impossible to go back and do it over again. Roll on time machines!
Not being a big fan of repetition, I found that 50% of a fairly lengthy poem using the same line over & over . . . it brought on a little eye-glazing-over in stretches. Even a tweak here & there, to break up the monotony & add some variance would make a big difference. I like your message & the way you hammer it home repetitively, which lends itself to some type of music, with a simple beat-like rhythm. My opinion is that there are many of these types of people who instantly run for danger instead of away from it. But not everyone is like that & not everyone could be a help in such a situation. Lots of people are barely holding themselves together against dire challenges. I'm not in agreement that everyone should be guilt-tripped into hero action. We each have our strengths & it's better to encourage people to do what they're good at. And we can also celebrate the heros that jump into the fire without hesitation. But I do appreciate the spots in your message where you're saying people just don't want to get involved or they're basically too lazy or uncaring to get involved. These kinds of people could use some prodding, as you do in your poem (((HUGS))) Fondly, Margie
Thank you, Margie, for your review; constructive and thoughtful, as always. I know your feelings abo.. read moreThank you, Margie, for your review; constructive and thoughtful, as always. I know your feelings about repetition because we have had this discussion before. I also know that you don't make much use of it in your own excellent work. It is just a point on which we can agree to disagree. I regard it as just another tool to make use of when I deem it appropriate. In this instance it is simply the hammer to drive the nail!
I agree with all of your points about the message, and would add that i expected this to be controversial when I wrote it. But you will note that I wrote it anyway. I believe this is a dark corner of city life that needed a light shone into it. I am certainly not advocating that fools should rush in where angels fear to tread.
Perhaps I could give you an example of the kind of thing I am talking by using an instance from my own life.
This occurred in London, England. I was on my way to a meeting during the rush hour, crossing London bridge at the time. I was recovering from a serious illness at the time and halfway across the bridge I was struck by a wave of pain so agonizing that my brain shut things down and I collapsed unconscious on the sidewalk. I don't know how long I was out for - it might have been two minutes, it might have been ten. When I recovered consciousness people were stepping over my body because it was blocking the sidewalk, but not one single person stopped to offer assistance! I was left to struggle to my feet on my own. As it happened I was right as rain after a five minute rest, but I could just as easily have been dying. That is the kind of situation where anybody could have helped, but no one did.
I could quote several other examples of similar conduct, but I think that one instance is sufficient to make my point.
I hope you had a good Easter.
6 Years Ago
Thanks for sharing more about your point of view . . . all your observations are well taken! *smile*
Aspiring new writer. I enjoy writing stories, poems and song lyrics. In fact most of my poems are song lyrics! All constructive input is welcome. If you think something sucks, tell me so. I won't be o.. more..