Gosh, Dear Fran Marie!
Magnetic imagery, alone, renders this marvelous Villanelle a virtual masterpiece of poetical enthrallment … deep and vibrant into my heart's wonder, the senses are filled to the brink by your softly engaging moments beneath the moon's and stars' embrace.
The picture brought to mind "Gothic" — yet, this piece is anything but, and I ached to be there with you, in the night (as you described it) had such a deep, alluring pull on my spirit … excellent poetry often effects me like this.
Brilliantly composed, Fran, you've dazzled with spot-on rhyme, captivating word choices and arrangement, following precisely and faithfully the rules for this amazing form, with but a couple of flow issues in V1L2 and V5L2 where count was lost. V4L2, consider "gladdened".
The depth and originality of your imagination are beguiling, to say the least, and your skills are such to make the boldest poet enviable.
Do I like it? Hah! No, I love it!
Thank you, Lovely Poetess, for sharing You with Us! ⁓ Richard
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
thanks so much Richard, for reading, and yes, I see what you mean on some count errors .. I will fix.. read morethanks so much Richard, for reading, and yes, I see what you mean on some count errors .. I will fix that up, I appreciate your review on my poetry and pointers on problem areas...
This poem was beautiful! You have great descriptions of your surroundings, and it made me feel like I was there on the scene. I think that everything ran smoothly, except the first line fo verse 2. There were just too many syllables in my opinion, but on the other hand, I don't see how else you could have worded it, so it really isn't your fault it came out like that. I was so pulled into your villanelle, it made me feel like I was reading a girls diary, it was such an exquisite poem. I am impressed by your rhyming skills because you didn't do it so that your poem sounded a little choppy. you made it so that everything just flowed through nicely, and that really is what made the structure of your poem. I really had a great time experiencing your story, because it had so much emotion inside of it. I do wish that you would have added a little bit more to your poem, maybe explain what you are feeling, instead of what the scene around the villanelle is making the reader feel. Add yourself to the poem. "I feel scared within my thoughts..." Something like that. That is how I would improve it, but I am not sure if that is a good idea to your or not. Otherwise, I really liked reading your villanelle, because it made my night (I read this while laying in my bed :p) I look forward to hearing more from you!
-Lily
Gosh, Dear Fran Marie!
Magnetic imagery, alone, renders this marvelous Villanelle a virtual masterpiece of poetical enthrallment … deep and vibrant into my heart's wonder, the senses are filled to the brink by your softly engaging moments beneath the moon's and stars' embrace.
The picture brought to mind "Gothic" — yet, this piece is anything but, and I ached to be there with you, in the night (as you described it) had such a deep, alluring pull on my spirit … excellent poetry often effects me like this.
Brilliantly composed, Fran, you've dazzled with spot-on rhyme, captivating word choices and arrangement, following precisely and faithfully the rules for this amazing form, with but a couple of flow issues in V1L2 and V5L2 where count was lost. V4L2, consider "gladdened".
The depth and originality of your imagination are beguiling, to say the least, and your skills are such to make the boldest poet enviable.
Do I like it? Hah! No, I love it!
Thank you, Lovely Poetess, for sharing You with Us! ⁓ Richard
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
thanks so much Richard, for reading, and yes, I see what you mean on some count errors .. I will fix.. read morethanks so much Richard, for reading, and yes, I see what you mean on some count errors .. I will fix that up, I appreciate your review on my poetry and pointers on problem areas...
"Answers on which I can rely
to life's myst'ry of destiny
Dwelling in sacred thoughts was I
Gazing up at the midnight sky"
The above lines are true. I enjoyed the journey in your words. Sometimes we must find the reasons and the purpose for our life. No weakness in the outstanding poetry.
Coyote
Posted 10 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
10 Years Ago
thanks so very much Coyote
10 Years Ago
You are welcome. Always a pleasure to read your words.
It's a reflective poem that expresses well the night sky's tendency to instill a serene contemplation. The refrains reflect this theme in their marriage, "sacred thoughts" being indelibly interlocked with the "midnight sky." Of villanelles, this is one of the most enchanting.