Hi. I was checking out another contest I got up the courage to enter and saw that you had entered it too with this poem. So I had to read this. It...it... is beautiful! So dark, so sad. It drips with melancholy and heartbreak. I love a poem about the dead that tells a story and has a twist. Excellent write. I can see you published this years ago, so i'm going to spend some time checking out some of your other work over the next few days.
Posted 10 Years Ago
3 of 3 people found this review constructive.
10 Years Ago
thanks Damien, so very much...so glad you are starting to enter contests...will be visiting your pag.. read morethanks Damien, so very much...so glad you are starting to enter contests...will be visiting your page soon...fm
I like this a lot. It's truly eerie and a great read. I would change some of the rhymes to make the poem flow more smoothly though. You truly want the rhyming to seem almost accidental. I do like the story behind this poem and how you portrayed it. Great job!
I finally entered a contest and saw this there and thought it seemed cool so I gave it a shot and read it and it was really great and so beautiful and dark and sad yet sweet.
I first thought he was going to be the one killing her but I loved the way it turned out! ^^
Great piece!
Posted 8 Years Ago
8 Years Ago
Thanks meena, so glad you enjoyed.. good luck on entering contests, they're lots of fun...
First up- Thanks for submitting your writing into my contest.
Now, to the review.
This is a fascinating piece of art. I like poems that rhymes. I have a hard time with those that don't!
We have here a pretty good story, and you could say that there are two 'Twists' or even three. The fact that she left him-- I was expecting him to murder her or something-- The fact that he took his own life--- And finally the fact that the POV is actually the lady for which he died.
I like it, it's a nice way to end it. But it does bring a few questions to mind;
Does he know who she is?
Cant he see her? She says they speak, and he tells her of his past, but if so does he not have a way to know to whom is he speaking?
Perhaps somet things are best left mysterious and vague.
Thank you for the poem!
Posted 8 Years Ago
8 Years Ago
Thanks for reading and reviewing..yes, he knows It is her but. She doesnt realize its her until th.. read moreThanks for reading and reviewing..yes, he knows It is her but. She doesnt realize its her until the end as she finally figures It out..he is there to tell her its time to come join him..perhaps she is in denile That It is her destiny to be with him..and finally gives up the ghost..commits suicide dir him as he has done dir her..hope That makes sense somewhat..
This... this is beautiful. Beautiful and absolutely heartbreaking. While the end didn't 100% surprise me, the way you concluded it is amazing! Toward the end, I suspected that the narrator was the lost love from his past, and the way you told the story and built it up to end... true heartache. I could feel the pain emanating from both the narrator and the Lady Love. Thank you so much for sharing this, and thank you even more for entering it in my contest!
Posted 10 Years Ago
10 Years Ago
Thanks Jade, so very much..its a pleasure entering this in your contest;
Hats off to you, Fran, for roundly defeating me in this contest, a contest which, I might add, I didn't even place in.
Sad write, this poem, a very melancholy musing of a dear lady committing suicide to be with her one and only true love, that ghost up in the sky.
Congratulations on winning the contest. I humbly bow before you...
Posted 10 Years Ago
10 Years Ago
Ahh,thanks so very much PloughBoy,I am sorry you didn't place...there are scads of contests and your.. read moreAhh,thanks so very much PloughBoy,I am sorry you didn't place...there are scads of contests and your writings are too good not to place or win in many contests...It's all up to votes or moderators...thanks again dear friend for reviews on my work..much appiciate it;
10 Years Ago
It's my pleasure, Fran, and again, congrats, and great job!
Thanks Sarah so very mch,for reviewing... .and for the winning award in your contest...much appricia.. read moreThanks Sarah so very mch,for reviewing... .and for the winning award in your contest...much appriciated
You have great rhythm and rhyme with this poem. It flowed beautifully throughout. The end popped out at me since I though at first the narrator was just the narrator and not one of the actual characters. This is tragically beautiful work. Keep it up!
-Kay