OOh. This one has a nice rhyme scheme, that flows perfectly. I think this is your best rhyming piece. I love the last line most of all. While your "youthfulness" is evident, as someone else pointed out, so is your talent. Quite the eleven year old, definitely. You better keep writing. You'll go wonderful places.
OOh. This one has a nice rhyme scheme, that flows perfectly. I think this is your best rhyming piece. I love the last line most of all. While your "youthfulness" is evident, as someone else pointed out, so is your talent. Quite the eleven year old, definitely. You better keep writing. You'll go wonderful places.
I think you were quite the 11 y/o. I was busy smoking cigarettes, playing barbies, and having my first "social" beers in the woods. In fact, what went on in the world outside my little part of it never interested me....until lately. I love this piece at it's the simple truth, and reminds me of a great old Scottish song called "Scottish Soldier". All about fighting a war on someone else's turf and I think dying there as well. That tune always brings tears to my eyes.
I loved the "unnatural causes" part. It really drives the nail in the coffin for me. It's the statement of the piece in my eyes. It's unnatural, unnecessary. I'd say as unnatural as war...but it seems man has been warring for as long as we've inhabited this earth so perhaps it is natural. ugh. I shudder to think, but think it I did.
The mam part was the hardest to take because I imagine that shadow to be her son stopping off to say goodbye on his way to heaven. Also....a parent losing a child is always a rough ordeal. Excellent work.
Hello Emily Elizabeth,
Look up on this site the work of Ron B. He is a Viet Nam Veteran and knows sniping from both ends of the gun. His work is a powerful inditement of the horrors of sniping. He has two relevent pieces, both short, both well worth looking at.
I see the 'youthfulness' in your poem and applaud the sentiments, thinking beyond your years at that time. A worthy piece.
'A misled stranger In an unknown land.' Now, in today's world, where would tat remind you of? Perhaps Messrs. Bush and Blair coukd tell us!
John
Posted 16 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
Advertise Here
Want to advertise here? Get started for as little as $5
I really enjoyed reading this. Great story, kinda sad, yet kinda light-hearted at parts? Atleast that's what I took away. Great job, particularly for year 11. :o!
Ah, now that was enjoyable! An all-around well written poem. It has quite the story to tell and holds the reader fixed on what the next image will bring.
I might criticize a bit about the starts of your first two stanzas, however. You've got:
"Johnny stood there"
and
"The opposition stood there"
The repetition is slightly awkward. The word "there" leaves the reader thinking "where is there", which can actually be quite beneficial, though using the word back to back hinders your poem, since the want for knowing where THERE is tends to overcome the desire for more of the poem itself.
I've kind of read it over, and it seems like it may be awkward to alter the second stanza to make it fit, though perhaps you could start it out with something such as:
"Johnny stood,
Gun in hand..."
Anyway, just a quick observation/suggestion. And well done again! Keep up the great work!
It's got a really good sense of spoken rhythm to the piece; and it's got a great cadence in terms of the last line, because it just seems to differ, in terms of the rhythm. I'm also curious about the little "x"s, though, I tried imagining the poem without them, and they did seem to sort of have a "start/end-scene" effect. Well, on me, anyway.