There’s a lot to writing poetry that’s not obvious, but is necessary. For example, if you’re going to rhyme then you need consistency in several areas
In general, the first stanza sets the structure. And in this you begin the first stanza with a line-to line rhyme structure of AABB. But Stanza 2 = ABCB. S3 = AAAA. S4 = AABC. S4 = AABC.
The number of beats, or feet, in the lines of S1, in most cases, should continue in each stanza. So S1’s structure is:
How COULD i conTINUE to FIGHT…? * Iambic, 4 feet, masculine (stressed syllable) ending.
…the PASSion THAT you igNITE? * Imabic, 3 feet, masculine ending.
Why DID i WAIT for so LONG? * Iambic, 3 feet, masculine ending. (I suggest dropping “for” to give smoother flow. The two unstressed words in a row can make the tongue stumble.
Our reLATIONship COULD have been FURther alONG. * Iambic, 4 feet, masculine ending.
The reader expects that stanza’s structure to continue. But S2…
i DON’T want to LOSE you as SOON as I’ve FOUND you. * Imbic, 4 feet, feminine ending.
IF I’m PULLED aWAY from YOU it WON’T be PRITty. * Trochaic, 6 feet Feminine ending.
I CAN’T leave-this TOWN with YOU arROUND. *Iambic 4 feet, masculine ending.
LOST and STRANDed withOUT you IN the BIG CITy. Trochaic, 6 feet (or 5 if you combine the last two words to a single foot), Masculine ending.
- - - - - - - -
The problem is, in our school years none of what I pointed out above was mentioned or taught, because there, we were learning the writing skills employers need from us, which is the ability to write reports and essays—nonfiction, in other words. And nonfiction is fact-based and dispassionate.
But our goal is to move the reader, emotionally. So instead of telling the reader we cried at a funeral, or for a broken relationship, we give the reader reason to weep. And that takes a very different approach—one not mentioned as existing in school.
Not the kind of news you hoped to hear, I know. But will we even address the problem we don’t see as being one? And to help with doing that, some suggestions:
Take a peek at the excerpt from Stephen Fry’s, The Ode Less Traveled, on Amazon. What he has to say about the flow of words in language may amaze you.
Then, download Mary Oliver’s, A Poetry Handbook from the address below. Lots of people swear by it.
https://yes-pdf.com/book/1596
And you might drop into the Shmoop site. Select Student, then, use the midpage button to select Poetry. They have lots of great poems, analyzed to show why and how they worked.
So jump in. Learning about something you want to do is far from a chore. And with the tricks at your disposal, writing poetry becomes more fun.
Hang in there, and keep on writing.
Jay Greenstein
https://jaygreenstein.wordpress.com/category/the-craft-of-writing/the-grumpy-old-writing-coach/
Posted 2 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
2 Years Ago
Thank you for your feedback. I will look into what you suggested.
I hope I posted thi.. read moreThank you for your feedback. I will look into what you suggested.
I hope I posted this comment in the right area. I had an account here years ago, but haven't thought of this site in a while. I had a nice friendship with someone on here, but after she decided to move on from this site I left for quite a long time. This might have been back in 2011 or 2012.
There’s a lot to writing poetry that’s not obvious, but is necessary. For example, if you’re going to rhyme then you need consistency in several areas
In general, the first stanza sets the structure. And in this you begin the first stanza with a line-to line rhyme structure of AABB. But Stanza 2 = ABCB. S3 = AAAA. S4 = AABC. S4 = AABC.
The number of beats, or feet, in the lines of S1, in most cases, should continue in each stanza. So S1’s structure is:
How COULD i conTINUE to FIGHT…? * Iambic, 4 feet, masculine (stressed syllable) ending.
…the PASSion THAT you igNITE? * Imabic, 3 feet, masculine ending.
Why DID i WAIT for so LONG? * Iambic, 3 feet, masculine ending. (I suggest dropping “for” to give smoother flow. The two unstressed words in a row can make the tongue stumble.
Our reLATIONship COULD have been FURther alONG. * Iambic, 4 feet, masculine ending.
The reader expects that stanza’s structure to continue. But S2…
i DON’T want to LOSE you as SOON as I’ve FOUND you. * Imbic, 4 feet, feminine ending.
IF I’m PULLED aWAY from YOU it WON’T be PRITty. * Trochaic, 6 feet Feminine ending.
I CAN’T leave-this TOWN with YOU arROUND. *Iambic 4 feet, masculine ending.
LOST and STRANDed withOUT you IN the BIG CITy. Trochaic, 6 feet (or 5 if you combine the last two words to a single foot), Masculine ending.
- - - - - - - -
The problem is, in our school years none of what I pointed out above was mentioned or taught, because there, we were learning the writing skills employers need from us, which is the ability to write reports and essays—nonfiction, in other words. And nonfiction is fact-based and dispassionate.
But our goal is to move the reader, emotionally. So instead of telling the reader we cried at a funeral, or for a broken relationship, we give the reader reason to weep. And that takes a very different approach—one not mentioned as existing in school.
Not the kind of news you hoped to hear, I know. But will we even address the problem we don’t see as being one? And to help with doing that, some suggestions:
Take a peek at the excerpt from Stephen Fry’s, The Ode Less Traveled, on Amazon. What he has to say about the flow of words in language may amaze you.
Then, download Mary Oliver’s, A Poetry Handbook from the address below. Lots of people swear by it.
https://yes-pdf.com/book/1596
And you might drop into the Shmoop site. Select Student, then, use the midpage button to select Poetry. They have lots of great poems, analyzed to show why and how they worked.
So jump in. Learning about something you want to do is far from a chore. And with the tricks at your disposal, writing poetry becomes more fun.
Hang in there, and keep on writing.
Jay Greenstein
https://jaygreenstein.wordpress.com/category/the-craft-of-writing/the-grumpy-old-writing-coach/
Posted 2 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
2 Years Ago
Thank you for your feedback. I will look into what you suggested.
I hope I posted thi.. read moreThank you for your feedback. I will look into what you suggested.
I hope I posted this comment in the right area. I had an account here years ago, but haven't thought of this site in a while. I had a nice friendship with someone on here, but after she decided to move on from this site I left for quite a long time. This might have been back in 2011 or 2012.