WOW, this is powerful and profound! It has strong imagery that paints a mystic picture of this mysterious man and the world. It's as though he's real. For he is real....in your heart, so it seems, and it's just so beautifully crafted in its metaphors and narrative. I'm honesty not that fond of Free Verse, but for this I can make an exception. WOW!
However, I do have a couple of notes, if you would allow me:
Free Verse, contrary to popular belief, does have "boundaries" and "restrictions". Poetry is all about making the words dance across the page, so you have to be careful with superfluous word and lines as well as unnecessary repetitions. With the former, an example is "I did not understand" (this stanza can easily be more powerful without that line - read it and you'll see/hear what I mean). With the latter, an example is the repetition of "this man" in the first couple of stanzas. Because they're in such close proximity, the repetition appears dull and drab, and you just don't need it. I get the sense that you're trying to repeat for emphasis, but there is such thing as overdoing a repetition (in which case it undermines the power it has). At least one of the repetitions should be replaced with a pronoun (the one in the solitary stanza can stay).
"antity" isn't a word....."entity" is.
That's about it. This is overall wonderful. Well done!
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thank you for your criticism! I will edit and post again.
WOW, this is powerful and profound! It has strong imagery that paints a mystic picture of this mysterious man and the world. It's as though he's real. For he is real....in your heart, so it seems, and it's just so beautifully crafted in its metaphors and narrative. I'm honesty not that fond of Free Verse, but for this I can make an exception. WOW!
However, I do have a couple of notes, if you would allow me:
Free Verse, contrary to popular belief, does have "boundaries" and "restrictions". Poetry is all about making the words dance across the page, so you have to be careful with superfluous word and lines as well as unnecessary repetitions. With the former, an example is "I did not understand" (this stanza can easily be more powerful without that line - read it and you'll see/hear what I mean). With the latter, an example is the repetition of "this man" in the first couple of stanzas. Because they're in such close proximity, the repetition appears dull and drab, and you just don't need it. I get the sense that you're trying to repeat for emphasis, but there is such thing as overdoing a repetition (in which case it undermines the power it has). At least one of the repetitions should be replaced with a pronoun (the one in the solitary stanza can stay).
"antity" isn't a word....."entity" is.
That's about it. This is overall wonderful. Well done!
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thank you for your criticism! I will edit and post again.
This is a very interesting and personal take on immigration. I like the way you personify this invisible man through the compassion of the person how loves him. The poem also has a nice rhythm.
I think you can be more concise. In the third line of the first stanza, 'this man' could be changed to 'he'. In the seventh stanza 'All humans have a number of which people identify them' could be changed to 'We all have an identity number' There are other examples too.
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thank you for your criticism! I will continue to edit my work.
I enjoy reading this poem, you illustrate very well with your words and bring us into your imagination. I enjoy the vague nature of this poem's focus yet the delivery doesn't rely specifically on sparse wording or vague phrases. I look forward to reading more of your work.
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Thank you for taking time out of your day to read my work. I look forward to investing my time into .. read moreThank you for taking time out of your day to read my work. I look forward to investing my time into your writing as well. Please correct tough, the more editing the better it will be. I would like to become a more simple writer.
This is great, and as you said on my one, this does paint a picture. A really deep picture of how ones life can change, in my opinion. I really hope you're okay!
Posted 6 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
6 Years Ago
Hello Siobhan! Thank you for your comments and I would love to chat with you outside of our writing... read moreHello Siobhan! Thank you for your comments and I would love to chat with you outside of our writing. You seem like my kind of writer.
6 Years Ago
Of course, any time you need a chat don't worry about messaging :-)
Thank you! I tried to be sneaky but I guess it doesn't work so well when you're writing becomes the .. read moreThank you! I tried to be sneaky but I guess it doesn't work so well when you're writing becomes the one thing that saves your life.
6 Years Ago
That was a weird response. Do you do a lot of drugs?