This is an intriguing poem. The choice of words in the phrase "open up your throat" is quite interesting. There are lots of different ways to say the same thing - "spit it out," "speak up," "talk to me," etc. - but this one, with the words "open" and "throat," seems to be simultaneously more painful and more personal. Though maybe that's just me... yay for poetry and openness to interpretation. :) I like the repetition of "won't tell me" and "closed lips", plus the line "then the answer's always no". All of these do a very good job of expressing the frustration behind this experience. The lines "I know it sucks, daddy's dumb, trying to tell you what you want, / So open up your throat so you can let him know" also speak to the frustration and pain of trying to help those we love, but being unable to do so because they close themselves and their needs off, causing them to become annoyed when we do try to help. Finally, the lines "Open up your throat, so your own world can grow" and "You need to scrape your voice from the corners of your mind" are powerful to me because they remind me of some of my feelings towards writing. Overall, a thought-provoking piece. Nice work!
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
Wow! Thank you for that absolutely wonderful analysis. A lot of people do poems about heart ache and.. read moreWow! Thank you for that absolutely wonderful analysis. A lot of people do poems about heart ache and I could do that quite easily, but I've been trying to come up with new yet still profound and relevant subject matters. I'm so glad you gained so much from it. The open up your throat, I was trying to illustrate talking in a phrase I never really heard.
This is an intriguing poem. The choice of words in the phrase "open up your throat" is quite interesting. There are lots of different ways to say the same thing - "spit it out," "speak up," "talk to me," etc. - but this one, with the words "open" and "throat," seems to be simultaneously more painful and more personal. Though maybe that's just me... yay for poetry and openness to interpretation. :) I like the repetition of "won't tell me" and "closed lips", plus the line "then the answer's always no". All of these do a very good job of expressing the frustration behind this experience. The lines "I know it sucks, daddy's dumb, trying to tell you what you want, / So open up your throat so you can let him know" also speak to the frustration and pain of trying to help those we love, but being unable to do so because they close themselves and their needs off, causing them to become annoyed when we do try to help. Finally, the lines "Open up your throat, so your own world can grow" and "You need to scrape your voice from the corners of your mind" are powerful to me because they remind me of some of my feelings towards writing. Overall, a thought-provoking piece. Nice work!
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
Wow! Thank you for that absolutely wonderful analysis. A lot of people do poems about heart ache and.. read moreWow! Thank you for that absolutely wonderful analysis. A lot of people do poems about heart ache and I could do that quite easily, but I've been trying to come up with new yet still profound and relevant subject matters. I'm so glad you gained so much from it. The open up your throat, I was trying to illustrate talking in a phrase I never really heard.
I like it.
Hard to speak our minds sometimes.
I can interpret this two ways. One good. One bad.
Posted 8 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
8 Years Ago
really? and how is the bad way? not offended just interested.
8 Years Ago
These lines, to someone who has been abused could lead to thoughts of a father that is sexually abus.. read moreThese lines, to someone who has been abused could lead to thoughts of a father that is sexually abusive and controlling : (Since you asked)
I know it sucks, daddy's dumb, trying to tell you what you want,
So open up your throat so you can let him know.
closed lips, closed lips, closed lips, closed lips, closed lips,
Everything can be interpreted, I hope that you are not offended. It depends on the reader really.
8 Years Ago
not at all, I think it's cool you picked up on something that I as the writer did not.
8 Years Ago
Someone once said something about the value being in the many interpretations or something like that.. read moreSomeone once said something about the value being in the many interpretations or something like that. I really can't remember to be honest... Anyhow, good work!
8 Years Ago
Was it if you say a piece of writing is about one thing, your probably right, but if you say it's ab.. read moreWas it if you say a piece of writing is about one thing, your probably right, but if you say it's about one thing your probably wrong; even if you wrote it. ?
Hi I'm Alex Benitez, and I'm a thirty year old amateur storyteller. I have two self published sci-fi adventure titles, Rose Star Runners, and it's sequel Rose Star Runners: and the Universe Princess. .. more..