What an interesting and creative spin on a child-hood classic. I don't pay much attention to rhyme and/or syllable count...but it still needs to read smoothly. When one tries to rewrite a song..unfortunately it's harder to break the rules of poetry because you have to find a similiar rhythm, or it feels broken when read aloud. Anyways...good first stab. You have some really good lines in there...but I would suggest that you focus on the rhythm and grammar a bit more. Nice work.
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
Thank you, Muse
I'd really appreciate it if you pointed the "rhythm and grammar" flaws
B.. read moreThank you, Muse
I'd really appreciate it if you pointed the "rhythm and grammar" flaws
Because most of of those who read it said nothing about this, also its written on a perfect 7 syllables meter! with slight crosses sometimes but still fits the original rhythm! Whoever tried to sing this conformed that
Help me out this blackening cell,
8 sylls...if.. read moreI am tired, lone and sad, "alone"
Help me out this blackening cell,
8 sylls...if you want to do 7 you must be exact all the way through.
you asked. ;)
11 Years Ago
For your first comment, lone serves the meaning fully!
And for 'Blackening' I guess you.. read moreFor your first comment, lone serves the meaning fully!
And for 'Blackening' I guess you are right! I am australian and when writing this I did by pronounce, when we say it, it sounds as 2 syllables!
Corrected now :)
Thanks
What an interesting and creative spin on a child-hood classic. I don't pay much attention to rhyme and/or syllable count...but it still needs to read smoothly. When one tries to rewrite a song..unfortunately it's harder to break the rules of poetry because you have to find a similiar rhythm, or it feels broken when read aloud. Anyways...good first stab. You have some really good lines in there...but I would suggest that you focus on the rhythm and grammar a bit more. Nice work.
Posted 11 Years Ago
1 of 1 people found this review constructive.
11 Years Ago
Thank you, Muse
I'd really appreciate it if you pointed the "rhythm and grammar" flaws
B.. read moreThank you, Muse
I'd really appreciate it if you pointed the "rhythm and grammar" flaws
Because most of of those who read it said nothing about this, also its written on a perfect 7 syllables meter! with slight crosses sometimes but still fits the original rhythm! Whoever tried to sing this conformed that
Help me out this blackening cell,
8 sylls...if.. read moreI am tired, lone and sad, "alone"
Help me out this blackening cell,
8 sylls...if you want to do 7 you must be exact all the way through.
you asked. ;)
11 Years Ago
For your first comment, lone serves the meaning fully!
And for 'Blackening' I guess you.. read moreFor your first comment, lone serves the meaning fully!
And for 'Blackening' I guess you are right! I am australian and when writing this I did by pronounce, when we say it, it sounds as 2 syllables!
Corrected now :)
Thanks
1st paragraph: "As I set and cry at night"... Do you mean "as I sit and cry at night"?
5th paragraph: "Where I'll find my twinkle star" should be "Where I'll find my twinkling star."
The wording in the sixth paragraph confused me. Also, "I set here alone and wait" should be "I sit here alone and wait."
I liked the line "I feel darkness in my heart / numbing all my twitching parts." It seemed sexually suggestive... haha.
This is an interesting way to re-write that classic song. I like your idea. However, I think you need to match the rhythm of the song a bit better. Try singing the lines you have written to the original tune and re-write anything that is awkward to sing. Each line should have 7 syllables.
Thank you, Naomi!
You made me realize I accidentally uploaded the draft!! may bad!
I'll .. read moreThank you, Naomi!
You made me realize I accidentally uploaded the draft!! may bad!
I'll edit it
"It seemed sexually suggestive" o.O I can't see that!
I honestly like this version better, what a remix to the original classic! :) It shows alot of pain and sadness. I can really relate to something like this. Its pure darkened beauty. :)
"A poet from the dark realm, from the world of Gothic hymns"
Please visit my website
http://adamnlebzo.wix.com/ronnin-warrior
Name: Adam lebzo
Age: 21
Hobbies: 1 Ninjutsu, Kung fu shaolin, Ji.. more..