Lonely Writers Blog Group : Forum : Confusing review


Confusing review

17 Years Ago


is this going to be a comedy?
I don't really know what to say.
some tension, must read on but duno if i will,
that might give you an idea

Does this mean he didn't like it or that he thinks it is a comedy

[no subject]

17 Years Ago


what? I dont even get that review. You could always ask the person to clarify what they were trying to say....

[no subject]

17 Years Ago


With a review as unclear as that, I would PM them and ask them to de-code it.

[no subject]

17 Years Ago


Such an adle-pated, inarticulate selection of phrases!

I suggest you disregard it.

Tell us what piece the review was for.

Surly and Old

[no subject]

17 Years Ago


Originally posted by surly and old

Such an adle-pated, inarticulate selection of phrases!

I suggest you disregard it.

Tell us what piece the review was for.

Surly and Old



I agree with Surly and Old (love the name!). I would either disregard it or pm them and ask them to decode it so others can understand it. I don't get it either.

[no subject]

17 Years Ago


Originally posted by Joan Cleaver's Shadow

is this going to be a comedy?
I don't really know what to say.
some tension, must read on but duno if i will,
that might give you an idea

Does this mean he didn't like it or that he thinks it is a comedy



I think the person is a moron. Anytime I get grammatically incorrect reviews, or ones rampant with spelling errors, I tend to take the review with a grain of salt. It doesn't even make sense.  "Some tension:" does that mean that it caused tension within the writer's mind, or there was "some tension" in the piece...whatever.

[no subject]

17 Years Ago


I have wrote him and he has not wrote me back grr