A B N A Vets Forum Semi-finalists Reviewing Other..

I'm curious on how everyone feels about semi-finalists reviewing other semi-finalists? I've read a few excerpts and plan to read more, but havent' done any reviews yet.   I just haven't made up my mind if, ethically, I should be doing reviews.

Anyone elses thoughts on this?

I think that if you think you can be objective, you should do it.

There's a couple of discussions of this going on at the official forum right now.  Some are saying you should be careful to give "customer" reviews, rather than "writer" reviews.  In other words, be honest about your reactions, but don't critique technical stuff or offer advice.

I'm not going to do any reviewing, because I don't have the time.

I'm still waiting to get a few reviews, and I'd welcome any and all, from anyone.